%PDF-1.6
%
1 0 obj
<>
endobj
2 0 obj
<>stream
Nynke van Miltenburg, Wojtek Przepiorka, Vincent Buskens
Consensual punishment does not promote cooperation in the six-person prisoner's dilemma game with noisy public monitoring
www.plosone.org
www.plosone.org
endstream
endobj
3 0 obj
<>/XObject<>>>/CropBox[0 0 612 792]/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]/Parent 9 0 R/Annots 10 0 R/Contents 11 0 R/TrimBox[0 0 612 792]>>
endobj
10 0 obj
[12 0 R 13 0 R 14 0 R 15 0 R 16 0 R 17 0 R 18 0 R 19 0 R 20 0 R 21 0 R 22 0 R 23 0 R 24 0 R 25 0 R 26 0 R 27 0 R 28 0 R 29 0 R 30 0 R 31 0 R 32 0 R 33 0 R 34 0 R 35 0 R 36 0 R 37 0 R 38 0 R 39 0 R 40 0 R]
endobj
12 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref008)>>
endobj
13 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref009)>>
endobj
14 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref010)>>
endobj
15 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref011)>>
endobj
16 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref012)>>
endobj
17 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref013)>>
endobj
18 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref014)>>
endobj
19 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref015)>>
endobj
20 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref016)>>
endobj
21 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref017)>>
endobj
22 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref018)>>
endobj
23 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref019)>>
endobj
24 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref013)>>
endobj
25 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref020)>>
endobj
26 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref021)>>
endobj
27 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref022)>>
endobj
28 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref023)>>
endobj
29 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref024)>>
endobj
30 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref025)>>
endobj
31 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref026)>>
endobj
32 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref027)>>
endobj
33 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref028)>>
endobj
34 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref027)>>
endobj
35 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref028)>>
endobj
36 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref016)>>
endobj
37 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref029)>>
endobj
38 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref030)>>
endobj
39 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref031)>>
endobj
40 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/A 41 0 R>>
endobj
41 0 obj
<>
endobj
11 0 obj
[42 0 R 43 0 R 44 0 R 45 0 R 46 0 R 47 0 R 48 0 R 49 0 R 50 0 R 51 0 R 52 0 R 53 0 R 54 0 R 55 0 R 56 0 R 57 0 R 58 0 R 59 0 R 60 0 R 61 0 R 62 0 R 63 0 R 64 0 R 65 0 R 66 0 R]
endobj
42 0 obj
<>stream
q
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
465.789 706.337 m
470.4945 706.337 l
h
f*
472.7622 706.337 m
477.5244 706.337 l
h
f*
276.9449 693.2976 m
286.4126 693.2976 l
h
f*
288.6803 693.2976 m
298.2047 693.2976 l
h
f*
300.4724 693.2976 m
309.9402 693.2976 l
h
f*
389.537 693.2976 m
399.0047 693.2976 l
h
f*
401.2724 693.2976 m
410.7969 693.2976 l
h
f*
233.5181 680.315 m
243.0425 680.315 l
h
f*
245.2535 680.315 m
254.778 680.315 l
h
f*
537.052 667.3323 m
546.5764 667.3323 l
h
f*
548.7874 667.3323 m
558.3118 667.3323 l
h
f*
481.4929 654.3496 m
491.0173 654.3496 l
h
f*
384.2646 589.3228 m
393.789 589.3228 l
h
f*
396.0567 589.3228 m
405.5811 589.3228 l
h
f*
407.7921 589.3228 m
417.3165 589.3228 l
h
f*
242.0787 550.3181 m
251.5465 550.3181 l
h
f*
257.2157 459.326 m
266.7402 459.326 l
h
f*
268.9512 459.326 m
278.4756 459.326 l
h
f*
280.7433 459.326 m
290.2677 459.326 l
h
f*
292.4787 459.326 m
302.0031 459.326 l
h
f*
387.4394 420.3213 m
396.9638 420.3213 l
h
f*
399.2315 420.3213 m
408.7559 420.3213 l
h
f*
431.2063 290.3244 m
440.7307 290.3244 l
h
f*
442.9984 290.3244 m
452.5228 290.3244 l
h
f*
299.8488 199.3323 m
309.3732 199.3323 l
h
f*
311.5843 199.3323 m
321.1087 199.3323 l
h
f*
323.3764 199.3323 m
332.9008 199.3323 l
h
f*
335.1118 199.3323 m
344.6362 199.3323 l
h
f*
0 g
1 j
1 J
0 w
10 0 0 10 200.0125 707.4141 cm
BT
/F5 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.004 Tc
0 0 Td
(has)Tj
1.542 0 Td
(been)Tj
2.1203 0 Td
(shown)Tj
2.8516 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7745 0 Td
(repeated)Tj
3.6397 0 Td
(interactions)Tj
4.9719 0 Td
(among)Tj
2.9934 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(same)Tj
2.2564 0 Td
(actors)Tj
2.6192 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(8)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(9)Tj
0 g
(],)Tj
2.3017 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(possibility)Tj
4.2746 0 Td
(for)Tj
1.3833 0 Td
(rep-)Tj
-35.6652 -1.3039 Td
(utation)Tj
3.0954 0 Td
(formation)Tj
4.2576 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(10)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(11)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(12)Tj
0 g
(],)Tj
4.422 0 Td
(peer)Tj
1.9502 0 Td
(sanctioning)Tj
4.8869 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(13)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(14)Tj
0 g
(],)Tj
3.2485 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7235 0 Td
(institutions)Tj
4.7621 0 Td
(facilitating)Tj
4.4561 0 Td
(these)Tj
2.245 0 Td
(mech-)Tj
-35.0473 -1.2982 Td
(anisms)Tj
3.0103 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(15)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(16)Tj
0 g
(])Tj
3.0274 0 Td
(can)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(promote)Tj
3.6623 0 Td
(collectively)Tj
4.6375 0 Td
(beneficial)Tj
4.0478 0 Td
(outcomes)Tj
4.0876 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(social)Tj
2.4604 0 Td
(dilemmas.)Tj
4.3427 0 Td
(Instigated)Tj
4.1839 0 Td
(by)Tj
-36.1188 -1.2983 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(success)Tj
3.1011 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(lab)Tj
1.4059 0 Td
(experimental)Tj
5.4595 0 Td
(approaches)Tj
4.7339 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(studying)Tj
3.6737 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.023 0 Td
(problems)Tj
3.9741 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(17)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(18)Tj
0 g
(],)Tj
-33.3635 -1.2983 Td
(peer-punishment)Tj
7.1432 0 Td
(has)Tj
1.542 0 Td
(been)Tj
2.126 0 Td
(controversially)Tj
6.1342 0 Td
(debated)Tj
3.3618 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.474 0 Td
(last)Tj
1.5591 0 Td
(15)Tj
1.1678 0 Td
(years)Tj
2.2677 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(19)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
-26.6114 -1.3039 Td
(Numerous)Tj
4.4957 0 Td
(studies)Tj
2.9877 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.0229 0 Td
(dilemmas)Tj
4.1216 0 Td
(consider)Tj
3.6453 0 Td
(settings)Tj
3.2428 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(which,)Tj
2.8743 0 Td
(after)Tj
2.0353 0 Td
(observing)Tj
4.1272 0 Td
(the)Tj
-35.8013 -1.2982 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.0229 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(their)Tj
2.109 0 Td
(peers,)Tj
2.5398 0 Td
(actors)Tj
2.6135 0 Td
(can)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(individually)Tj
4.9889 0 Td
(decide)Tj
2.8177 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0204 0 Td
(reduce)Tj
2.9197 0 Td
(their)Tj
2.109 0 Td
(peers')Tj
2.5284 0 Td
(payoffs)Tj
3.0728 0 Td
(at)Tj
0.9524 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(cost)Tj
-35.9884 -1.2983 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(themselves.)Tj
4.7848 0 Td
(We)Tj
1.6044 0 Td
(call)Tj
1.5704 0 Td
(this)Tj
1.6781 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(peer)Tj
1.9559 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.057 0 Td
(institution)Tj
4.4106 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7802 0 Td
(employs)Tj
3.5489 0 Td
(an)Tj
1.2019 0 Td
(`individual)Tj
4.5127 0 Td
(decision)Tj
-33.783 -1.3039 Td
(rule')Tj
2.0012 0 Td
(\(henceforth)Tj
4.8982 0 Td
(IDR\).)Tj
2.4832 0 Td
(In)Tj
1.1111 0 Td
(these)Tj
2.2564 0 Td
(studies,)Tj
3.2088 0 Td
(actors)Tj
2.6135 0 Td
(typically)Tj
3.566 0 Td
(observe)Tj
3.2655 0 Td
(each)Tj
2.0296 0 Td
(other's)Tj
2.9253 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.023 0 Td
(accu-)Tj
-35.3818 -1.2983 Td
(rately)Tj
2.4434 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7235 0 Td
(high)Tj
2.0069 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.0173 0 Td
(rates)Tj
2.1033 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4456 0 Td
(reached)Tj
3.3449 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(13)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(20)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(21)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
4.4277 0 Td
(However,)Tj
4.0705 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(numerous)Tj
4.303 0 Td
(real)Tj
1.6894 0 Td
(world)Tj
2.5512 0 Td
(set-)Tj
-36.1585 -1.2983 Td
(tings,)Tj
2.3867 0 Td
(individuals)Tj
4.6488 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4457 0 Td
(provided)Tj
3.8154 0 Td
(with)Tj
2.0012 0 Td
(imprecise)Tj
4.0932 0 Td
(information)Tj
5.074 0 Td
(about)Tj
2.4945 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.0286 0 Td
(or)Tj
1.0942 0 Td
(defection)Tj
-33.5506 -1.3039 Td
(of)Tj
1.0147 0 Td
(others.)Tj
2.9311 0 Td
(Such)Tj
2.1769 0 Td
(situations)Tj
4.0876 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4513 0 Td
(described)Tj
4.0535 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(being)Tj
2.4321 0 Td
(subject)Tj
3.0161 0 Td
(to)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.0261 0 Td
[()12()15()4()2()-23()9()7()-4()]TJ
3.8211 0 Td
[()11( )14(\n)10()12()4()]TJ
2.5738 0 Td
[()6()11(\r)18()14()11()11()-9()12(\r)13()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
4.5921 0 Td
(or,)Tj
1.321 0 Td
(sim-)Tj
-35.5122 -1.2982 Td
(ply,)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.661 0 Td
[(\r)6()11()-4()-3()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
2.2054 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(22)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
-2.6702 -1.2983 Td
(We)Tj
1.61 0 Td
(study)Tj
2.3925 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(effect)Tj
2.3641 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(noise)Tj
2.33 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2756 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.023 0 Td
(under)Tj
2.6192 0 Td
(peer)Tj
1.9559 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.0569 0 Td
(institutions)Tj
4.7736 0 Td
(by)Tj
1.1792 0 Td
(means)Tj
-34.2593 -1.3039 Td
(of)Tj
1.0147 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(laboratory)Tj
4.354 0 Td
(experiment)Tj
4.7735 0 Td
(with)Tj
2.0013 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(six-person)Tj
4.3937 0 Td
(prisoner's)Tj
4.1612 0 Td
(dilemma)Tj
3.7587 0 Td
(\(PD\))Tj
2.194 0 Td
(game.)Tj
2.5852 0 Td
(In)Tj
1.1112 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(experi-)Tj
-33.9361 -1.2983 Td
(mental)Tj
2.9876 0 Td
(conditions)Tj
4.4788 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.9955 0 Td
(noise,)Tj
2.5512 0 Td
(actors)Tj
2.6135 0 Td
(know)Tj
2.4605 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7745 0 Td
(they)Tj
1.9275 0 Td
(observe)Tj
3.2655 0 Td
(other)Tj
2.3471 0 Td
(group)Tj
2.6135 0 Td
(members')Tj
4.1556 0 Td
(coopera-)Tj
-33.1708 -1.2982 Td
(tion)Tj
1.8425 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(defection)Tj
3.9231 0 Td
(\(or)Tj
1.44 0 Td
(vice)Tj
1.7858 0 Td
(versa\))Tj
2.6078 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.9956 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6577 0 Td
(certain)Tj
2.982 0 Td
(probability.)Tj
4.8245 0 Td
(The)Tj
1.7802 0 Td
(effect)Tj
2.364 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(noise)Tj
2.3301 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2756 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
-31.8385 -1.2983 Td
(has)Tj
1.542 0 Td
(been)Tj
2.1203 0 Td
(studied)Tj
3.1521 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(context)Tj
3.1861 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(infinitely)Tj
3.8324 0 Td
(repeated)Tj
3.634 0 Td
(PD)Tj
1.5194 0 Td
(games,)Tj
2.948 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(which)Tj
2.6532 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.023 0 Td
(can)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(be)Tj
-35.79 -1.3039 Td
(sustained)Tj
3.9684 0 Td
(through)Tj
3.4469 0 Td
(direct)Tj
2.5285 0 Td
(reciprocity,)Tj
4.7679 0 Td
(if)Tj
0.7767 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(probability)Tj
4.5978 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(encountering)Tj
5.5728 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(same)Tj
2.262 0 Td
(actors)Tj
2.6135 0 Td
(again)Tj
2.3698 0 Td
(is)Tj
-36.8558 -1.2983 Td
(large)Tj
2.1599 0 Td
(enough)Tj
3.2202 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(23)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(24)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(25)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(26)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
5.6069 0 Td
(Here)Tj
2.2053 0 Td
(we)Tj
1.3266 0 Td
(study)Tj
2.3868 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.474 0 Td
(effect)Tj
2.3641 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(noise)Tj
2.3243 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2756 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(efficacy)Tj
3.2258 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(peer-punish-)Tj
-31.0675 -1.2983 Td
(ment)Tj
2.3073 0 Td
(institutions)Tj
4.7736 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(promote)Tj
3.6623 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.023 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(one-shot)Tj
3.7417 0 Td
(encounters.)Tj
-20.3753 -1.3039 Td
(It)Tj
0.8617 0 Td
(has)Tj
1.542 0 Td
(been)Tj
2.1203 0 Td
(shown)Tj
2.8517 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7744 0 Td
(noise)Tj
2.3301 0 Td
(can)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(lead)Tj
1.8482 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(misguided)Tj
4.405 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.0627 0 Td
(decisions)Tj
3.9061 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(thus)Tj
1.9332 0 Td
(limit)Tj
2.1203 0 Td
(the)Tj
-36.3342 -1.2982 Td
(effectiveness)Tj
5.2043 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(an)Tj
1.2019 0 Td
(IDR)Tj
1.9162 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(sustain)Tj
3.0161 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.023 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(27)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(28)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
3.2541 0 Td
(For)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(example,)Tj
3.7757 0 Td
(let)Tj
1.1906 0 Td
(us)Tj
1.1055 0 Td
(assume)Tj
3.1464 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7801 0 Td
(co-)Tj
-34.2819 -1.2983 Td
(workers)Tj
3.4355 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.9956 0 Td
(different)Tj
3.6567 0 Td
(expertise)Tj
3.77 0 Td
(work)Tj
2.2791 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2755 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(common)Tj
3.8494 0 Td
(project.)Tj
3.2428 0 Td
(While)Tj
2.6476 0 Td
(one)Tj
1.7008 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(them,)Tj
2.5114 0 Td
(person)Tj
2.9481 0 Td
(A,)Tj
-34.9793 -1.3039 Td
(may)Tj
1.9275 0 Td
(put)Tj
1.5647 0 Td
(little)Tj
1.9956 0 Td
(effort)Tj
2.3981 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(project,)Tj
3.2428 0 Td
(her)Tj
1.542 0 Td
(co-workers,)Tj
4.9436 0 Td
(who)Tj
1.9389 0 Td
(know)Tj
2.4548 0 Td
(little)Tj
2.0013 0 Td
(about)Tj
2.4888 0 Td
(A's)Tj
1.4853 0 Td
(field,)Tj
2.194 0 Td
(may)Tj
1.9276 0 Td
(believe)Tj
-34.6108 -1.2983 Td
(that)Tj
1.7744 0 Td
(she)Tj
1.5364 0 Td
(made)Tj
2.4208 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6576 0 Td
(sincere)Tj
3.0387 0 Td
(contribution.)Tj
5.5162 0 Td
(Conversely,)Tj
4.8982 0 Td
(suppose)Tj
3.4356 0 Td
(person)Tj
2.948 0 Td
(B)Tj
0.7994 0 Td
(offers)Tj
2.4604 0 Td
(valuable)Tj
3.4923 0 Td
(input)Tj
2.3811 0 Td
(that)Tj
-35.3591 -1.2983 Td
(appears)Tj
3.2768 0 Td
(small,)Tj
2.5511 0 Td
(but)Tj
1.5534 0 Td
(which)Tj
2.6532 0 Td
(requires)Tj
3.4696 0 Td
(considerable)Tj
5.2611 0 Td
(work)Tj
2.279 0 Td
(behind)Tj
3.0217 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(scenes.)Tj
2.9877 0 Td
(Co-workers)Tj
4.9549 0 Td
(who)Tj
1.9389 0 Td
(did)Tj
-35.4158 -1.2982 Td
(not)Tj
1.5703 0 Td
(observe)Tj
3.2712 0 Td
(B's)Tj
1.372 0 Td
(real)Tj
1.6951 0 Td
(effort)Tj
2.3981 0 Td
(may)Tj
1.9275 0 Td
(come)Tj
2.3924 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0262 0 Td
(believe)Tj
2.965 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7801 0 Td
(B)Tj
0.7994 0 Td
(did)Tj
1.542 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.5761 0 Td
(contribute)Tj
4.3937 0 Td
(his)Tj
1.3719 0 Td
(fair)Tj
1.5817 0 Td
(share.)Tj
2.5625 0 Td
(As)Tj
1.2643 0 Td
(the)Tj
-35.4895 -1.3039 Td
(value)Tj
2.3073 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(common)Tj
3.8437 0 Td
(project)Tj
3.0161 0 Td
(depends)Tj
3.5489 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2756 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.474 0 Td
(actual)Tj
2.5795 0 Td
(contributions,)Tj
5.879 0 Td
(all)Tj
1.1452 0 Td
(co-workers)Tj
4.7169 0 Td
(benefit)Tj
2.9763 0 Td
(from)Tj
-35.2457 -1.2983 Td
(B's)Tj
1.3719 0 Td
(but)Tj
1.5534 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.576 0 Td
(from)Tj
2.2054 0 Td
(A's)Tj
1.4797 0 Td
(effort.)Tj
2.6248 0 Td
(However,)Tj
4.0762 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(some)Tj
2.3301 0 Td
(will)Tj
1.6611 0 Td
(misperceive)Tj
4.9719 0 Td
(A's)Tj
1.4797 0 Td
(and/or)Tj
2.9423 0 Td
(B's)Tj
1.372 0 Td
(contributions,)Tj
5.879 0 Td
(B)Tj
-36.5383 -1.2983 Td
(may)Tj
1.9275 0 Td
(be)Tj
1.1509 0 Td
(criticized)Tj
3.9004 0 Td
(for)Tj
1.389 0 Td
(free-riding,)Tj
4.7451 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7348 0 Td
(A)Tj
0.9014 0 Td
(may)Tj
1.9276 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.576 0 Td
(be)Tj
1.1509 0 Td
(sufficiently)Tj
4.6148 0 Td
(reprimanded)Tj
5.4481 0 Td
(for)Tj
1.389 0 Td
(shirking.)Tj
-31.8555 -1.3039 Td
(These)Tj
2.5681 0 Td
(sanctions)Tj
3.9685 0 Td
(or)Tj
1.0942 0 Td
(their)Tj
2.1089 0 Td
(absence,)Tj
3.566 0 Td
(respectively,)Tj
5.1137 0 Td
(can)Tj
1.6214 0 Td
(occur)Tj
2.4774 0 Td
(even)Tj
2.0693 0 Td
(though)Tj
3.0727 0 Td
(A's)Tj
1.4797 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(B's)Tj
1.3777 0 Td
(colleagues)Tj
-32.2467 -1.2982 Td
(know)Tj
2.4547 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7802 0 Td
(they)Tj
1.9219 0 Td
(might)Tj
2.5965 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.576 0 Td
(observe)Tj
3.2655 0 Td
(A's)Tj
1.4854 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(B's)Tj
1.372 0 Td
(true)Tj
1.8425 0 Td
(efforts)Tj
2.7552 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(27)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(28)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
3.2542 0 Td
(As)Tj
1.2642 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6576 0 Td
(consequence,)Tj
5.5616 0 Td
(B)Tj
0.7994 0 Td
(may)Tj
1.9275 0 Td
(be)Tj
-36.2435 -1.2983 Td
(discouraged)Tj
5.0569 0 Td
(from)Tj
2.2054 0 Td
(putting)Tj
3.1407 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(same)Tj
2.2564 0 Td
(amount)Tj
3.3562 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(effort)Tj
2.3981 0 Td
(again,)Tj
2.5908 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7292 0 Td
(A)Tj
0.9071 0 Td
(may)Tj
1.9275 0 Td
(be)Tj
1.1509 0 Td
(encouraged)Tj
4.8699 0 Td
(to)Tj
-35.1097 -1.3039 Td
(continue)Tj
3.7643 0 Td
(shirking.)Tj
3.7474 0 Td
(In)Tj
1.1112 0 Td
(both)Tj
2.0579 0 Td
(cases,)Tj
2.4491 0 Td
(noise)Tj
2.3244 0 Td
(has)Tj
1.5421 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6576 0 Td
(detrimental)Tj
4.8756 0 Td
(effect)Tj
2.3641 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2755 0 Td
(cooperation.)Tj
-24.973 -1.2983 Td
(An)Tj
1.457 0 Td
(alternative)Tj
4.4163 0 Td
(peer)Tj
1.9559 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.0627 0 Td
(institution)Tj
4.405 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7801 0 Td
(might)Tj
2.5965 0 Td
(better)Tj
2.5455 0 Td
(support)Tj
3.3165 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.0287 0 Td
(under)Tj
-33.7604 -1.2983 Td
(noise)Tj
2.3243 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8504 0 Td
(one)Tj
1.7008 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7745 0 Td
(employs)Tj
3.5489 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6577 0 Td
(collective)Tj
3.9288 0 Td
(decision)Tj
3.5489 0 Td
(rule)Tj
1.7858 0 Td
(\(henceforth)Tj
4.9039 0 Td
(CDR\),)Tj
2.8063 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(which)Tj
2.6532 0 Td
(punishments)Tj
-31.5153 -1.3039 Td
(are)Tj
1.4456 0 Td
(only)Tj
1.9786 0 Td
(carried)Tj
3.0387 0 Td
(out)Tj
1.5534 0 Td
(if)Tj
0.7767 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6519 0 Td
(certain)Tj
2.9877 0 Td
(proportion)Tj
4.6318 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(actors)Tj
2.6135 0 Td
(agrees)Tj
2.6986 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(punish)Tj
2.9707 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(particular)Tj
4.1102 0 Td
(group)Tj
2.6079 0 Td
(mem-)Tj
-34.7582 -1.2982 Td
(ber.)Tj
1.7461 0 Td
(Numerous)Tj
4.4957 0 Td
(social)Tj
2.4548 0 Td
(groups)Tj
2.9707 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7801 0 Td
(face)Tj
1.7858 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.0287 0 Td
(problems)Tj
3.9684 0 Td
(employ)Tj
3.1918 0 Td
(collective)Tj
3.9345 0 Td
(decisions)Tj
3.9061 0 Td
(to)Tj
-35.2627 -1.2983 Td
(implement)Tj
4.5807 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.0627 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(16)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(29)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(30)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(31)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
5.6068 0 Td
(With)Tj
2.2791 0 Td
(noise,)Tj
2.5512 0 Td
(some)Tj
2.33 0 Td
(peers)Tj
2.3187 0 Td
(correctly)Tj
3.7361 0 Td
(observe)Tj
3.2711 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(cooperation,)Tj
-32.3884 -1.2983 Td
(while)Tj
2.3697 0 Td
(others)Tj
2.7042 0 Td
(observe)Tj
3.2712 0 Td
(it)Tj
0.7824 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0147 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6577 0 Td
(defection)Tj
3.9231 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7348 0 Td
(may)Tj
1.9275 0 Td
(punish)Tj
2.9707 0 Td
(accordingly.)Tj
5.1137 0 Td
(If)Tj
0.8447 0 Td
(more)Tj
2.3414 0 Td
(actors)Tj
2.6136 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4513 0 Td
(required)Tj
-33.7207 -1.3039 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(agree,)Tj
2.5625 0 Td
(it)Tj
0.7823 0 Td
(becomes)Tj
3.6851 0 Td
(less)Tj
1.61 0 Td
(likely)Tj
2.3584 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7745 0 Td
(such)Tj
2.0636 0 Td
(`misguided')Tj
4.8472 0 Td
(punishments)Tj
5.4198 0 Td
(aimed)Tj
2.6929 0 Td
(at)Tj
0.9525 0 Td
(cooperators)Tj
4.9379 0 Td
(are)Tj
-34.7128 -1.2983 Td
(implemented.)Tj
5.7599 0 Td
(At)Tj
1.2019 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(same)Tj
2.2621 0 Td
(time,)Tj
2.2507 0 Td
(consensus)Tj
4.2802 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2756 0 Td
(punishing)Tj
4.252 0 Td
(true)Tj
1.8425 0 Td
(defectors)Tj
3.8437 0 Td
(might)Tj
2.5966 0 Td
(be)Tj
1.1508 0 Td
(difficult)Tj
3.3562 0 Td
(to)Tj
-35.5405 -1.2982 Td
(reach,)Tj
2.6248 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(one)Tj
1.7008 0 Td
(or)Tj
1.0942 0 Td
(several)Tj
2.9366 0 Td
(potential)Tj
3.7587 0 Td
(punishers)Tj
4.1273 0 Td
(may)Tj
1.9275 0 Td
(observe)Tj
3.2655 0 Td
(defectors)Tj
3.8438 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(cooperators.)Tj
-26.1126 -1.3039 Td
(Hence,)Tj
3.033 0 Td
(CDRs)Tj
2.6022 0 Td
(present)Tj
3.1634 0 Td
(both)Tj
2.0637 0 Td
(an)Tj
1.2018 0 Td
(advantage)Tj
4.2406 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7292 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6519 0 Td
(disadvantage)Tj
5.3972 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.9955 0 Td
(regard)Tj
2.812 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(implementing)Tj
-31.1128 -1.2983 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.0569 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(noisy)Tj
2.3584 0 Td
(environments.)Tj
6.0151 0 Td
(The)Tj
1.7858 0 Td
(magnitude)Tj
4.5297 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(both)Tj
2.058 0 Td
(effects)Tj
2.7269 0 Td
(depends)Tj
3.5489 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2756 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(required)Tj
-32.876 -1.2983 Td
(degree)Tj
2.8516 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(consensus.)Tj
4.507 0 Td
(Our)Tj
1.8652 0 Td
(aim)Tj
1.7405 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8504 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(identify)Tj
3.2938 0 Td
(an)Tj
1.2019 0 Td
(optimal)Tj
3.3109 0 Td
(decision)Tj
3.5433 0 Td
(rule)Tj
1.7914 0 Td
(for)Tj
1.3833 0 Td
(encouraging)Tj
5.2044 0 Td
(coopera-)Tj
-33.5846 -1.3039 Td
(tion)Tj
1.8425 0 Td
(under)Tj
2.6135 0 Td
(noisy)Tj
2.3584 0 Td
(conditionsa)Tj
5.8337 0 Td
(rule)Tj
1.7914 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7802 0 Td
(enables)Tj
3.1634 0 Td
(actors)Tj
2.6136 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(identify)Tj
3.2938 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7292 0 Td
(punish)Tj
2.9706 0 Td
(defectors,)Tj
4.0706 0 Td
(while)Tj
-35.087 -1.2982 Td
(cooperators)Tj
4.9379 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4513 0 Td
(unlikely)Tj
3.4299 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(be)Tj
1.1509 0 Td
(punished)Tj
3.9175 0 Td
(erroneously.)Tj
5.1873 0 Td
(In)Tj
1.1112 0 Td
(our)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(experiment,)Tj
5.0003 0 Td
(we)Tj
1.3266 0 Td
(compare)Tj
3.719 0 Td
(an)Tj
1.2019 0 Td
(IDR)Tj
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
576 737.1 m
36 737.1 l
36 737.6 l
576 737.6 l
f*
36 741.2598 107.1496 23.6976 re
W* n
q
107.0929 0 0 23.6409 36 741.3165 cm
q
/I0 Do
Q
Q
Q
q
0 0 612 792 re
W* n
1 j
1 J
0 w
7.9999 0 0 7.9999 203.811 745.7952 cm
BT
/F0 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.005 Tc
0 0 Td
(Consens)Tj
3.8764 0 Td
(ual)Tj
1.5236 0 Td
(punishmen)Tj
4.8048 0 Td
(t)Tj
0.496 0 Td
(does)Tj
2.3528 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.5803 0 Td
(promote)Tj
3.8339 0 Td
(coopera)Tj
3.5433 0 Td
(tion)Tj
1.8001 0 Td
(in)Tj
0.9779 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.5874 0 Td
(six-person)Tj
4.7481 0 Td
(prisoner's)Tj
4.4717 0 Td
(dilemma)Tj
3.9331 0 Td
(game)Tj
2.6788 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.9701 0 Td
(noise)Tj
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
36 48.0002 m
576 48.0002 l
576 47.5002 l
36 47.5002 l
f*
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
81.5811 34.9228 m
237.8835 34.9228 l
h
f*
0 g
7.9999 0 0 7.9999 36 36 cm
BT
/F0 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.005 Tc
0 0 Td
(PLOS)Tj
2.8559 0 Td
(ONE)Tj
2.3669 0 Td
(|)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
0.4748 0 Td
(https://doi.or)Tj
5.4142 0 Td
(g/10.137)Tj
3.8198 0 Td
(1/journal.po)Tj
5.1236 0 Td
(ne.01885)Tj
4.089 0 Td
(03)Tj
0 g
2.0906 0 Td
(November)Tj
4.7622 0 Td
(27,)Tj
1.5875 0 Td
(2017)Tj
32.5561 0 Td
(2)Tj
0.7654 0 Td
(/)Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
43 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
44 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
45 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
46 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
47 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
48 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
49 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
50 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
51 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
52 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
53 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
54 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
55 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
56 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
57 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
58 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
59 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
60 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
61 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
62 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
63 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
64 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
65 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
66 0 obj
<>stream
BT
66.402 0 Td
(20)Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
67 0 obj
<>/XObject<>>>/CropBox[0 0 612 792]/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]/Parent 9 0 R/Annots 69 0 R/Contents 70 0 R/TrimBox[0 0 612 792]>>
endobj
69 0 obj
[71 0 R 72 0 R 73 0 R 74 0 R 75 0 R 76 0 R 77 0 R 78 0 R 79 0 R 80 0 R 81 0 R 82 0 R 83 0 R 84 0 R 85 0 R 86 0 R 87 0 R 88 0 R 89 0 R 90 0 R 91 0 R 92 0 R 93 0 R 94 0 R 95 0 R 96 0 R 97 0 R]
endobj
71 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref032)>>
endobj
72 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref033)>>
endobj
73 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref034)>>
endobj
74 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref020)>>
endobj
75 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref021)>>
endobj
76 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref035)>>
endobj
77 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref036)>>
endobj
78 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref037)>>
endobj
79 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref038)>>
endobj
80 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref022)>>
endobj
81 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref039)>>
endobj
82 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref040)>>
endobj
83 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref040)>>
endobj
84 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref041)>>
endobj
85 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref042)>>
endobj
86 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref015)>>
endobj
87 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref016)>>
endobj
88 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref043)>>
endobj
89 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref044)>>
endobj
90 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref045)>>
endobj
91 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref046)>>
endobj
92 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref047)>>
endobj
93 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref048)>>
endobj
94 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref028)>>
endobj
95 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref049)>>
endobj
96 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref050)>>
endobj
97 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/A 98 0 R>>
endobj
98 0 obj
<>
endobj
70 0 obj
[99 0 R 100 0 R 101 0 R 102 0 R 103 0 R 104 0 R 105 0 R 106 0 R 107 0 R 108 0 R 109 0 R 110 0 R 111 0 R 112 0 R 113 0 R 114 0 R 115 0 R 116 0 R 117 0 R 118 0 R 119 0 R 120 0 R 121 0 R 122 0 R 123 0 R 124 0 R 125 0 R]
endobj
99 0 obj
<>stream
q
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
431.5465 523.8992 m
441.0709 523.8992 l
h
f*
203.4142 497.9339 m
212.9386 497.9339 l
h
f*
215.1496 497.9339 m
224.674 497.9339 l
h
f*
241.852 471.9118 m
251.3764 471.9118 l
h
f*
253.5874 471.9118 m
263.1118 471.9118 l
h
f*
265.3795 471.9118 m
274.9039 471.9118 l
h
f*
277.115 471.9118 m
286.6394 471.9118 l
h
f*
408.2457 458.9291 m
417.7701 458.9291 l
h
f*
420.0378 458.9291 m
429.5622 458.9291 l
h
f*
203.4142 432.9071 m
212.9386 432.9071 l
h
f*
215.1496 432.9071 m
224.674 432.9071 l
h
f*
226.9417 432.9071 m
236.4661 432.9071 l
h
f*
251.8866 406.9417 m
261.411 406.9417 l
h
f*
301.6063 380.9197 m
311.074 380.9197 l
h
f*
313.3417 380.9197 m
322.8661 380.9197 l
h
f*
477.3543 354.8976 m
486.8787 354.8976 l
h
f*
489.1465 354.8976 m
498.6709 354.8976 l
h
f*
500.8819 354.8976 m
510.4063 354.8976 l
h
f*
512.674 354.8976 m
522.1984 354.8976 l
h
f*
477.8646 328.9323 m
487.389 328.9323 l
h
f*
434.4378 315.9496 m
443.9622 315.9496 l
h
f*
446.1732 315.9496 m
455.6976 315.9496 l
h
f*
457.9654 315.9496 m
467.4898 315.9496 l
h
f*
500.8252 289.9276 m
510.3496 289.9276 l
h
f*
499.1244 237.9402 m
508.6488 237.9402 l
h
f*
463.011 185.8961 m
472.4787 185.8961 l
h
f*
0 g
1 j
1 J
0 w
10 0 0 10 200.0125 707.4141 cm
BT
/F5 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.004 Tc
0 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.9955 0 Td
(two)Tj
1.7121 0 Td
(CDRs)Tj
2.6022 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(series)Tj
2.4265 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(one-shot)Tj
3.7474 0 Td
(six-person)Tj
4.388 0 Td
(PD)Tj
1.5193 0 Td
(games)Tj
2.7213 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.9955 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7348 0 Td
(without)Tj
3.3279 0 Td
(noise.)Tj
2.5511 0 Td
(The)Tj
1.7859 0 Td
(first)Tj
-34.5541 -1.3039 Td
(CDR)Tj
2.2393 0 Td
(places)Tj
2.6249 0 Td
(minor)Tj
2.7326 0 Td
(restrictions)Tj
4.7224 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2756 0 Td
(collective)Tj
3.9288 0 Td
(agreement,)Tj
4.6545 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(second)Tj
3.0161 0 Td
(requires)Tj
3.4695 0 Td
(majority)Tj
3.6284 0 Td
(consen-)Tj
-33.7604 -1.2982 Td
(sus.)Tj
1.6951 0 Td
(All)Tj
1.3946 0 Td
(conditions)Tj
4.4787 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4457 0 Td
(preceded)Tj
3.8607 0 Td
(by)Tj
1.1792 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(series)Tj
2.4321 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(one-shot,)Tj
3.9685 0 Td
(six-person)Tj
4.388 0 Td
(PD)Tj
1.5193 0 Td
(games)Tj
2.7213 0 Td
(without)Tj
3.3278 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6577 0 Td
(peer-)Tj
-34.7355 -1.2983 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.0569 0 Td
(opportunity,)Tj
5.2611 0 Td
(which)Tj
2.6532 0 Td
(we)Tj
1.3266 0 Td
(call)Tj
1.5704 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(baseline)Tj
3.4299 0 Td
(condition.)Tj
-19.5702 -1.2983 Td
(In)Tj
1.1111 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(remainder)Tj
4.4107 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(this)Tj
1.6724 0 Td
(paper,)Tj
2.7099 0 Td
(we)Tj
1.3266 0 Td
(first)Tj
1.8028 0 Td
(summarize)Tj
4.6601 0 Td
(previous)Tj
3.651 0 Td
(findings)Tj
3.4923 0 Td
(from)Tj
2.2053 0 Td
(related)Tj
2.9424 0 Td
(experi-)Tj
-33.664 -1.3039 Td
(mental)Tj
2.9876 0 Td
(studies.)Tj
3.2145 0 Td
(We)Tj
1.6101 0 Td
(then)Tj
2.0182 0 Td
(describe)Tj
3.5206 0 Td
(our)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(experimental)Tj
5.4595 0 Td
(games,)Tj
2.948 0 Td
(derive)Tj
2.6873 0 Td
(our)Tj
1.627 0 Td
(hypotheses,)Tj
4.8472 0 Td
(describe)Tj
3.5263 0 Td
(the)Tj
-36.0734 -1.2982 Td
(experimental)Tj
5.4594 0 Td
(design)Tj
2.812 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(procedure,)Tj
4.5354 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7348 0 Td
(present)Tj
3.1635 0 Td
(our)Tj
1.627 0 Td
(results.)Tj
3.0331 0 Td
(We)Tj
1.6101 0 Td
(conclude)Tj
3.8437 0 Td
(our)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(paper)Tj
2.4831 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.9956 0 Td
(a)Tj
-35.6539 -1.2983 Td
(discussion)Tj
4.3709 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(our)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(findings)Tj
3.4923 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(light)Tj
2.0239 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(previous)Tj
3.651 0 Td
(research.)Tj
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
11.9999 0 0 11.9999 200.0125 580.9889 cm
BT
/F2 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.0033 Tc
0 0 Td
(Related)Tj
3.7984 0 Td
(literature)Tj
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
10 0 0 10 200.0125 563.9811 cm
BT
/F5 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.004 Tc
0 0 Td
(In)Tj
1.1055 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.474 0 Td
(abundant)Tj
4.0421 0 Td
(experimental)Tj
5.4595 0 Td
(literature)Tj
3.8835 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2756 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.0229 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(peer)Tj
1.9559 0 Td
(punishment,)Tj
5.2838 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6576 0 Td
(number)Tj
3.4129 0 Td
(of)Tj
-35.3024 -1.2982 Td
(findings)Tj
3.4922 0 Td
(have)Tj
2.058 0 Td
(been)Tj
2.1259 0 Td
(frequently)Tj
4.3087 0 Td
(replicated.)Tj
4.3766 0 Td
(In)Tj
1.1112 0 Td
(one-shot)Tj
3.7417 0 Td
(interactions)Tj
4.9663 0 Td
(without)Tj
3.3335 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
-29.5141 -1.2983 Td
(options,)Tj
3.4525 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.023 0 Td
(rates)Tj
2.109 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4456 0 Td
(typically)Tj
3.566 0 Td
(considerable,)Tj
5.4821 0 Td
(but)Tj
1.5534 0 Td
(depend)Tj
3.1861 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2756 0 Td
(specific)Tj
3.1918 0 Td
(properties)Tj
4.2803 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(the)Tj
-35.5802 -1.3039 Td
(situation,)Tj
3.9514 0 Td
(exact)Tj
2.2677 0 Td
(payoffs,)Tj
3.2939 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(characteristics)Tj
5.9073 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(individuals)Tj
4.6488 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(32)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
2.075 0 Td
(If)Tj
0.8504 0 Td
(interactions)Tj
4.9662 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4514 0 Td
(finitely)Tj
-32.156 -1.2983 Td
(repeated)Tj
3.6396 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.9956 0 Td
(changing)Tj
3.9004 0 Td
(partners,)Tj
3.7701 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.023 0 Td
(typically)Tj
3.5659 0 Td
(declines)Tj
3.4413 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0204 0 Td
(lower)Tj
2.4548 0 Td
(levels)Tj
2.3754 0 Td
(over)Tj
1.9786 0 Td
(time)Tj
-33.1651 -1.2982 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(33)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(34)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
3.2428 0 Td
(Behaviors)Tj
4.1385 0 Td
(change)Tj
3.0387 0 Td
(considerably)Tj
5.2838 0 Td
(when)Tj
2.3981 0 Td
(peer)Tj
1.9445 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.0513 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.99 0 Td
(an)Tj
1.1962 0 Td
(IDR)Tj
1.9105 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8391 0 Td
(employed.)Tj
4.3596 0 Td
(Typi-)Tj
-35.3931 -1.3039 Td
(cally,)Tj
2.2506 0 Td
(high)Tj
2.007 0 Td
(levels)Tj
2.3754 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.0229 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4514 0 Td
(reached)Tj
3.3505 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(maintained)Tj
4.7905 0 Td
(because)Tj
3.3166 0 Td
(many)Tj
2.4774 0 Td
(subjects)Tj
3.3789 0 Td
(punish)Tj
-33.1651 -1.2983 Td
(defectors)Tj
3.8437 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(20)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(21)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(35)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(36)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
5.6069 0 Td
(However,)Tj
4.0762 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(recent)Tj
2.7042 0 Td
(years,)Tj
2.4945 0 Td
(evidence)Tj
3.7077 0 Td
(has)Tj
1.542 0 Td
(accumulated)Tj
5.3064 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7802 0 Td
(peer)Tj
1.9559 0 Td
(punish-)Tj
-34.0552 -1.2983 Td
(ment)Tj
2.3073 0 Td
(with)Tj
2.0013 0 Td
(an)Tj
1.2019 0 Td
(IDR)Tj
1.9162 0 Td
(can)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(also)Tj
1.7688 0 Td
(have)Tj
2.0579 0 Td
(detrimental)Tj
4.8812 0 Td
(effects)Tj
2.7213 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(37)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(38)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
3.2541 0 Td
(For)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(example,)Tj
3.7757 0 Td
(many)Tj
2.4775 0 Td
(studies)Tj
2.982 0 Td
(find)Tj
1.8539 0 Td
(a)Tj
-36.4533 -1.2982 Td
(small)Tj
2.3243 0 Td
(proportion)Tj
4.6318 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(defectors)Tj
3.8438 0 Td
(who)Tj
1.9389 0 Td
(punish)Tj
2.9707 0 Td
(cooperators,)Tj
5.1646 0 Td
(which)Tj
2.6533 0 Td
(negatively)Tj
4.2349 0 Td
(affects)Tj
2.7382 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
-31.5153 -1.304 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(22)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(39)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(40)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
4.4276 0 Td
(Henceforth,)Tj
5.023 0 Td
(we)Tj
1.3323 0 Td
(refer)Tj
2.0976 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0205 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.0626 0 Td
(directed)Tj
3.4809 0 Td
(at)Tj
0.9525 0 Td
(defectors)Tj
3.8437 0 Td
(as)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.0148 0 Td
[()11()20()7()-3()4()1()4()11()]TJ
3.6794 0 Td
[()11( )12(\r)18()-4()12()18()6()2(\r)22()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(,)Tj
-31.9349 -1.2982 Td
(because)Tj
3.3165 0 Td
(it)Tj
0.788 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8504 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(collective)Tj
3.9345 0 Td
(interest,)Tj
3.4412 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.057 0 Td
(directed)Tj
3.4866 0 Td
(at)Tj
0.9524 0 Td
(cooperators)Tj
4.938 0 Td
(as)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.0148 0 Td
[()16(\r)22()7()-4()-3()4()1()4()11()]TJ
-32.0086 -1.2983 Td
[()11( )12(\r)18()-4()12()18()6()2(\r)22()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
4.8472 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(40)Tj
0 g
(],)Tj
2.0806 0 Td
(because)Tj
3.3165 0 Td
(it)Tj
0.788 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8504 0 Td
(detrimental)Tj
4.8756 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(collective)Tj
3.9345 0 Td
(interest.)Tj
3.4355 0 Td
(Moreover,)Tj
4.3937 0 Td
(since)Tj
2.245 0 Td
(peer)Tj
1.9559 0 Td
(punish-)Tj
-33.749 -1.3039 Td
(ment)Tj
2.3073 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8504 0 Td
(costly,)Tj
2.7326 0 Td
(many)Tj
2.4775 0 Td
(iterations)Tj
3.9968 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4513 0 Td
(required)Tj
3.6397 0 Td
(before)Tj
2.7382 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(benefits)Tj
3.3392 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(increased)Tj
3.9968 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.0286 0 Td
(out-)Tj
-35.0416 -1.2983 Td
(weigh)Tj
2.5851 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.0627 0 Td
(costs)Tj
2.1713 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(41)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(42)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
-8.6229 -1.2982 Td
(A)Tj
0.907 0 Td
(growing)Tj
3.5263 0 Td
(body)Tj
2.2167 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(research)Tj
3.5546 0 Td
(suggests)Tj
3.4866 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7745 0 Td
(centralized)Tj
4.5978 0 Td
(sanctioning)Tj
4.8925 0 Td
(institutions)Tj
4.7679 0 Td
(have)Tj
2.0579 0 Td
(evolved)Tj
-33.9928 -1.3039 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(overcome)Tj
4.1499 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(detrimental)Tj
4.8756 0 Td
(effects)Tj
2.7269 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(peer)Tj
1.9559 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.0626 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.9956 0 Td
(an)Tj
1.2019 0 Td
(IDR)Tj
1.9162 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(15)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(16)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(43)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(44)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
5.6069 0 Td
(For)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(exam-)Tj
-34.6278 -1.2983 Td
(ple,)Tj
1.6327 0 Td
(it)Tj
0.7824 0 Td
(has)Tj
1.542 0 Td
(been)Tj
2.126 0 Td
(argued)Tj
2.9707 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7744 0 Td
(pool-punishment)Tj
7.1886 0 Td
(institutions,)Tj
4.9947 0 Td
(where)Tj
2.6532 0 Td
(free-riders)Tj
4.3993 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4457 0 Td
(punished)Tj
3.9231 0 Td
(by)Tj
1.1792 0 Td
(a)Tj
-36.612 -1.2983 Td
(central)Tj
2.965 0 Td
(authority)Tj
3.9061 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7801 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8448 0 Td
(maintained)Tj
4.7905 0 Td
(through)Tj
3.4412 0 Td
(voluntary)Tj
4.0649 0 Td
(contributions)Tj
5.6522 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(45)Tj
0 g
(],)Tj
2.075 0 Td
(have)Tj
2.0636 0 Td
(played)Tj
2.8233 0 Td
(an)Tj
-34.4067 -1.2982 Td
(important)Tj
4.2802 0 Td
(role)Tj
1.7688 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(maintaining)Tj
5.1137 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.0286 0 Td
(at)Tj
0.9525 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6519 0 Td
(large)Tj
2.16 0 Td
(scale)Tj
2.109 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(46)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(47)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(48)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
4.4277 0 Td
(An)Tj
1.4513 0 Td
(important)Tj
4.2859 0 Td
(but)Tj
1.5534 0 Td
(under-)Tj
-34.8205 -1.304 Td
(studied)Tj
3.1521 0 Td
(aspect)Tj
2.6758 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(this)Tj
1.6724 0 Td
(strand)Tj
2.761 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(research)Tj
3.5546 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8504 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(procedure)Tj
4.3143 0 Td
(by)Tj
1.1792 0 Td
(which)Tj
2.6532 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(central)Tj
2.965 0 Td
(authority)Tj
3.9061 0 Td
(decides)Tj
-33.8567 -1.2982 Td
(whom)Tj
2.7552 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(punish,)Tj
3.1975 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(particular,)Tj
4.337 0 Td
(if)Tj
0.7767 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.0229 0 Td
(cannot)Tj
2.9821 0 Td
(perfectly)Tj
3.668 0 Td
(be)Tj
1.1452 0 Td
(observed)Tj
3.7984 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(28)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
2.0749 0 Td
(Our)Tj
1.8652 0 Td
(study)Tj
-33.681 -1.2983 Td
(contributes)Tj
4.7508 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(this)Tj
1.6725 0 Td
(strand)Tj
2.7609 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(research)Tj
3.5603 0 Td
(by)Tj
1.1792 0 Td
(comparing)Tj
4.5751 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(effectiveness)Tj
5.2044 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(individual)Tj
4.2859 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7292 0 Td
(collec-)Tj
-34.2423 -1.3039 Td
(tive)Tj
1.661 0 Td
(decision)Tj
3.549 0 Td
(rules)Tj
2.1486 0 Td
(for)Tj
1.3833 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.474 0 Td
(implementation)Tj
6.6387 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.057 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0262 0 Td
(maintain)Tj
3.838 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.023 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(noisy)Tj
-33.8511 -1.2983 Td
(environments.)Tj
6.015 0 Td
(Only)Tj
2.2167 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(few)Tj
1.6157 0 Td
(studies)Tj
2.9877 0 Td
(have)Tj
2.0636 0 Td
(addressed)Tj
4.1726 0 Td
(closely)Tj
2.8856 0 Td
(related)Tj
2.9424 0 Td
(issues.)Tj
-24.3551 -1.2982 Td
(Two)Tj
2.0239 0 Td
(studies)Tj
2.9877 0 Td
(address)Tj
3.2258 0 Td
(peer)Tj
1.9559 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.057 0 Td
(through)Tj
3.4469 0 Td
(CDRs.)Tj
2.8289 0 Td
(Casari)Tj
2.7496 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(Luini)Tj
2.3698 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(49)Tj
0 g
(])Tj
1.8538 0 Td
(study)Tj
2.3868 0 Td
(groups)Tj
2.9707 0 Td
(of)Tj
-36.7821 -1.304 Td
(five)Tj
1.6497 0 Td
(subjects.)Tj
3.6056 0 Td
(Under)Tj
2.829 0 Td
(their)Tj
2.109 0 Td
(CDR,)Tj
2.4661 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.057 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8504 0 Td
(implemented)Tj
5.5332 0 Td
(if)Tj
0.7766 0 Td
(at)Tj
0.9525 0 Td
(least)Tj
1.9842 0 Td
(two)Tj
1.7065 0 Td
(subjects)Tj
3.3788 0 Td
(punish)Tj
2.9707 0 Td
(the)Tj
-35.8693 -1.2982 Td
(same)Tj
2.2563 0 Td
(group)Tj
2.6079 0 Td
(member.)Tj
3.8097 0 Td
(The)Tj
1.7858 0 Td
(authors)Tj
3.2428 0 Td
(find)Tj
1.8539 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7801 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.023 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(earnings)Tj
3.6397 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4513 0 Td
(higher)Tj
2.8006 0 Td
(under)Tj
2.6192 0 Td
(the)Tj
-34.5994 -1.2983 Td
(CDR)Tj
2.2393 0 Td
(than)Tj
2.0296 0 Td
(under)Tj
2.6192 0 Td
(an)Tj
1.2019 0 Td
(IDR,)Tj
2.143 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(antisocial)Tj
4.0081 0 Td
(punishments)Tj
5.4198 0 Td
(hinder)Tj
2.8857 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.0229 0 Td
(under)Tj
2.6192 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(IDR)Tj
1.9218 0 Td
(but)Tj
1.5534 0 Td
(are)Tj
-36.1471 -1.3039 Td
(not)Tj
1.5703 0 Td
(typically)Tj
3.566 0 Td
(implemented)Tj
5.5332 0 Td
(under)Tj
2.6192 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(CDR.)Tj
2.4661 0 Td
(Van)Tj
1.8992 0 Td
(Miltenburg)Tj
4.7679 0 Td
(et)Tj
0.9411 0 Td
(al.)Tj
1.1282 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(50)Tj
0 g
(])Tj
1.8481 0 Td
(examine)Tj
3.6 0 Td
(groups)Tj
2.9707 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(four)Tj
-35.3931 -1.2983 Td
(actors.)Tj
2.8402 0 Td
(Two)Tj
2.0183 0 Td
(CDRs)Tj
2.6022 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4513 0 Td
(employed:)Tj
4.3653 0 Td
(one)Tj
1.7008 0 Td
(for)Tj
1.3833 0 Td
(which)Tj
2.6532 0 Td
(two)Tj
1.7065 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(one)Tj
1.7008 0 Td
(for)Tj
1.3889 0 Td
(which)Tj
2.6476 0 Td
(all)Tj
1.1452 0 Td
(three)Tj
2.2677 0 Td
(remaining)Tj
-31.6004 -1.2982 Td
(group)Tj
2.6078 0 Td
(members)Tj
3.9458 0 Td
(must)Tj
2.228 0 Td
(target)Tj
2.5058 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.474 0 Td
(same)Tj
2.2564 0 Td
(recipient)Tj
3.7587 0 Td
(for)Tj
1.389 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.057 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(be)Tj
1.1509 0 Td
(carried)Tj
3.0387 0 Td
(out.)Tj
1.7801 0 Td
(In)Tj
1.1055 0 Td
(this)Tj
1.6781 0 Td
(study,)Tj
-35.0019 -1.2983 Td
(antisocial)Tj
4.0024 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.0627 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8504 0 Td
(rare)Tj
1.8198 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(does)Tj
2.0353 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.576 0 Td
(affect)Tj
2.3755 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.0229 0 Td
(even)Tj
2.0693 0 Td
(under)Tj
2.6192 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.474 0 Td
(IDR.)Tj
2.143 0 Td
(Moreover,)Tj
-32.7796 -1.3039 Td
(prosocial)Tj
3.855 0 Td
(punishments)Tj
5.4199 0 Td
(attempted)Tj
4.2576 0 Td
(under)Tj
2.6192 0 Td
(CDRs)Tj
2.6021 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4514 0 Td
(often)Tj
2.2847 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.576 0 Td
(implemented.)Tj
5.76 0 Td
(Consequently,)Tj
5.9527 0 Td
(it)Tj
0.788 0 Td
(is)Tj
-36.5666 -1.2983 Td
(found)Tj
2.6191 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7745 0 Td
(both)Tj
2.0636 0 Td
(contributions)Tj
5.6523 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(earnings)Tj
3.6397 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4456 0 Td
(lower)Tj
2.4548 0 Td
(when)Tj
2.4038 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6519 0 Td
(broader)Tj
3.3619 0 Td
(consensus)Tj
4.286 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8447 0 Td
(required)Tj
3.6396 0 Td
(to)Tj
-36.5666 -1.2982 Td
(enact)Tj
2.347 0 Td
(punishments.)Tj
-1.1508 -1.304 Td
(Both)Tj
2.1373 0 Td
(studies)Tj
2.982 0 Td
(use)Tj
1.5364 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(linear)Tj
2.5115 0 Td
(public)Tj
2.7099 0 Td
(goods)Tj
2.5852 0 Td
(game)Tj
2.3641 0 Td
(\(PGG\))Tj
2.8856 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(which)Tj
2.6532 0 Td
(subjects)Tj
3.3789 0 Td
(do)Tj
1.2529 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.5704 0 Td
(only)Tj
1.9785 0 Td
(decide)Tj
-34.2479 -1.2982 Td
(whether)Tj
3.4752 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(contribute,)Tj
4.6148 0 Td
(but)Tj
1.5534 0 Td
(also)Tj
1.7688 0 Td
(how)Tj
1.9389 0 Td
(much)Tj
2.5171 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0262 0 Td
(contribute.)Tj
4.6204 0 Td
(We)Tj
1.6101 0 Td
(consider)Tj
3.6453 0 Td
(CDRs)Tj
2.6022 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(a)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.6519 0 Td
[(\r)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(-person)Tj
3.8268 0 Td
(PD)Tj
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
576 737.1 m
36 737.1 l
36 737.6 l
576 737.6 l
f*
36 741.2598 107.1496 23.6976 re
W* n
q
107.0929 0 0 23.6409 36 741.3165 cm
q
/I0 Do
Q
Q
Q
q
0 0 612 792 re
W* n
1 j
1 J
0 w
7.9999 0 0 7.9999 203.811 745.7952 cm
BT
/F0 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.005 Tc
0 0 Td
(Consens)Tj
3.8764 0 Td
(ual)Tj
1.5236 0 Td
(punishmen)Tj
4.8048 0 Td
(t)Tj
0.496 0 Td
(does)Tj
2.3528 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.5803 0 Td
(promote)Tj
3.8339 0 Td
(coopera)Tj
3.5433 0 Td
(tion)Tj
1.8001 0 Td
(in)Tj
0.9779 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.5874 0 Td
(six-person)Tj
4.7481 0 Td
(prisoner's)Tj
4.4717 0 Td
(dilemma)Tj
3.9331 0 Td
(game)Tj
2.6788 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.9701 0 Td
(noise)Tj
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
36 48.0002 m
576 48.0002 l
576 47.5002 l
36 47.5002 l
f*
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
81.5811 34.9228 m
237.8835 34.9228 l
h
f*
0 g
7.9999 0 0 7.9999 36 36 cm
BT
/F0 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.005 Tc
0 0 Td
(PLOS)Tj
2.8559 0 Td
(ONE)Tj
2.3669 0 Td
(|)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
0.4748 0 Td
(https://doi.or)Tj
5.4142 0 Td
(g/10.137)Tj
3.8198 0 Td
(1/journal.po)Tj
5.1236 0 Td
(ne.01885)Tj
4.089 0 Td
(03)Tj
0 g
2.0906 0 Td
(November)Tj
4.7622 0 Td
(27,)Tj
1.5875 0 Td
(2017)Tj
32.5561 0 Td
(3)Tj
0.7654 0 Td
(/)Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
100 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
101 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
102 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
103 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
104 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
105 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
106 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
107 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
108 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
109 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
110 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
111 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
112 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
113 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
114 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
115 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
116 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
117 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
118 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
119 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
120 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
121 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
122 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
123 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
124 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
125 0 obj
<>stream
BT
66.402 0 Td
(20)Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
126 0 obj
<>/XObject<>>>/CropBox[0 0 612 792]/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]/Parent 9 0 R/Annots 130 0 R/Contents 131 0 R/TrimBox[0 0 612 792]>>
endobj
130 0 obj
[132 0 R 133 0 R 134 0 R 135 0 R 136 0 R 137 0 R 138 0 R 139 0 R 140 0 R 141 0 R 142 0 R 143 0 R 144 0 R 145 0 R 146 0 R 147 0 R 148 0 R 149 0 R 150 0 R]
endobj
132 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref049)>>
endobj
133 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref027)>>
endobj
134 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref028)>>
endobj
135 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref027)>>
endobj
136 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref028)>>
endobj
137 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref027)>>
endobj
138 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref028)>>
endobj
139 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref041)>>
endobj
140 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref051)>>
endobj
141 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref052)>>
endobj
142 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref053)>>
endobj
143 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref054)>>
endobj
144 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref055)>>
endobj
145 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref056)>>
endobj
146 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref001)>>
endobj
147 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref002)>>
endobj
148 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref020)>>
endobj
149 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref021)>>
endobj
150 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/A 151 0 R>>
endobj
151 0 obj
<>
endobj
131 0 obj
[152 0 R 153 0 R 154 0 R 155 0 R 156 0 R 157 0 R 158 0 R 159 0 R 160 0 R 161 0 R 162 0 R 163 0 R 164 0 R 165 0 R 166 0 R 167 0 R 168 0 R]
endobj
152 0 obj
<>stream
q
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
447.3071 667.3323 m
456.8315 667.3323 l
h
f*
279.8929 641.3102 m
289.4173 641.3102 l
h
f*
367.5402 641.3102 m
377.0646 641.3102 l
h
f*
471.515 576.3402 m
481.0394 576.3402 l
h
f*
559.2189 576.3402 m
568.7433 576.3402 l
h
f*
420.1512 537.3354 m
429.6756 537.3354 l
h
f*
424.7433 524.2961 m
434.211 524.2961 l
h
f*
444.8693 446.3433 m
454.3937 446.3433 l
h
f*
456.6614 446.3433 m
466.1291 446.3433 l
h
f*
468.3969 446.3433 m
477.9213 446.3433 l
h
f*
408.4157 433.3039 m
417.9402 433.3039 l
h
f*
490.8472 302.9102 m
500.3717 302.9102 l
h
f*
502.6394 302.9102 m
512.1638 302.9102 l
h
f*
514.3748 302.9102 m
523.8992 302.9102 l
h
f*
265.5496 172.9134 m
270.3118 172.9134 l
h
f*
272.5795 172.9134 m
277.3417 172.9134 l
h
f*
441.8646 159.9307 m
451.389 159.9307 l
h
f*
453.6567 159.9307 m
463.1811 159.9307 l
h
f*
0 g
1 j
1 J
0 w
10 0 0 10 200.0125 707.4141 cm
BT
/F5 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.004 Tc
0 0 Td
(setting)Tj
2.8799 0 Td
(where)Tj
2.6532 0 Td
(subjects)Tj
3.3789 0 Td
(merely)Tj
2.9594 0 Td
(decide)Tj
2.8119 0 Td
(whether)Tj
3.4753 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(contribute)Tj
4.388 0 Td
(their)Tj
2.109 0 Td
(full)Tj
1.5307 0 Td
(endowment)Tj
5.0003 0 Td
(or)Tj
1.0998 0 Td
(nothing)Tj
3.3789 0 Td
(at)Tj
-36.6914 -1.3039 Td
(all.)Tj
1.3719 0 Td
(Compared)Tj
4.4844 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0205 0 Td
(experiments)Tj
5.142 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7801 0 Td
(use)Tj
1.5307 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(linear)Tj
2.5115 0 Td
(PGG,)Tj
2.4377 0 Td
(our)Tj
1.6214 0 Td
(clear)Tj
2.1204 0 Td
(distinction)Tj
4.5354 0 Td
(between)Tj
3.5262 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
-32.7342 -1.2982 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(defection)Tj
3.9288 0 Td
(may)Tj
1.9275 0 Td
(facilitate)Tj
3.6 0 Td
(consensus)Tj
4.2803 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2756 0 Td
(punishing)Tj
4.2519 0 Td
(defectors.)Tj
4.0705 0 Td
(At)Tj
1.2019 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(same)Tj
2.2564 0 Td
(time,)Tj
2.2564 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6519 0 Td
(linear)Tj
2.5115 0 Td
(PGG)Tj
-35.4101 -1.2983 Td
(may)Tj
1.9275 0 Td
(facilitate)Tj
3.6 0 Td
(consensus)Tj
4.2803 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2755 0 Td
(punishing)Tj
4.252 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(lowest)Tj
2.7383 0 Td
(contributor)Tj
4.8472 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(49)Tj
0 g
(],)Tj
2.0806 0 Td
(which)Tj
2.6475 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8504 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.5704 0 Td
(possible)Tj
3.4129 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(our)Tj
-35.9827 -1.2983 Td
(setting)Tj
2.8799 0 Td
(if)Tj
0.7767 0 Td
(more)Tj
2.3414 0 Td
(than)Tj
2.0296 0 Td
(one)Tj
1.6951 0 Td
(actor)Tj
2.2564 0 Td
(defects.)Tj
-10.7829 -1.3039 Td
(Grechenig)Tj
4.388 0 Td
(et)Tj
0.9411 0 Td
(al.)Tj
1.1225 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(27)Tj
0 g
(])Tj
1.8482 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(Fischer)Tj
3.1237 0 Td
(et)Tj
0.9411 0 Td
(al.)Tj
1.1225 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(28)Tj
0 g
(])Tj
1.8482 0 Td
(experimentally)Tj
6.1625 0 Td
(examine)Tj
3.6 0 Td
(how)Tj
1.9332 0 Td
(noise)Tj
2.3301 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(display)Tj
-34.7865 -1.2982 Td
(of)Tj
1.0147 0 Td
(contributions)Tj
5.6523 0 Td
(affects)Tj
2.7326 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.474 0 Td
(extent)Tj
2.6759 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(which)Tj
2.6475 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.023 0 Td
(can)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(be)Tj
1.1508 0 Td
(maintained)Tj
4.7906 0 Td
(through)Tj
3.4469 0 Td
(punish-)Tj
-33.2615 -1.2983 Td
(ment)Tj
2.3073 0 Td
(institutions)Tj
4.7736 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.9955 0 Td
(an)Tj
1.2019 0 Td
(IDR.)Tj
2.143 0 Td
(Both)Tj
2.1316 0 Td
(studies)Tj
2.9877 0 Td
(consider)Tj
3.651 0 Td
(linear)Tj
2.5115 0 Td
(PGGs)Tj
2.5682 0 Td
(with)Tj
2.0012 0 Td
(noise.)Tj
2.5512 0 Td
(Noise)Tj
2.5115 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8504 0 Td
(imple-)Tj
-34.1856 -1.3039 Td
(mented)Tj
3.2598 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6519 0 Td
(10%)Tj
1.9332 0 Td
(or)Tj
1.0942 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6576 0 Td
(50%)Tj
1.9276 0 Td
(probability)Tj
4.5978 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6519 0 Td
(contribution)Tj
5.2894 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0262 0 Td
(be)Tj
1.1508 0 Td
(observed)Tj
3.7984 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(random)Tj
3.4299 0 Td
(amount.)Tj
-33.1651 -1.2983 Td
(This)Tj
1.9842 0 Td
(renders)Tj
3.2485 0 Td
(noise)Tj
2.3244 0 Td
(more)Tj
2.3414 0 Td
(ambiguous)Tj
4.6374 0 Td
(than)Tj
2.0296 0 Td
(it)Tj
0.788 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8448 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0374 0 Td
(our)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(setting,)Tj
3.1068 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(which)Tj
2.6532 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6519 0 Td
(misrepresented)Tj
6.3609 0 Td
(contri-)Tj
-34.6674 -1.2983 Td
(bution)Tj
2.8743 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8504 0 Td
(always)Tj
2.8289 0 Td
(shown)Tj
2.8516 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(defection)Tj
3.9288 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7292 0 Td
(vice)Tj
1.7858 0 Td
(versa.)Tj
2.4944 0 Td
(Grechenig)Tj
4.3824 0 Td
(et)Tj
0.9411 0 Td
(al.)Tj
1.1282 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(27)Tj
0 g
(])Tj
1.8481 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7348 0 Td
(Fischer)Tj
3.1181 0 Td
(et)Tj
0.9411 0 Td
(al.)Tj
1.1282 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(28)Tj
0 g
(])Tj
-35.5802 -1.3039 Td
(find)Tj
1.8481 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7802 0 Td
(subjects)Tj
3.3788 0 Td
(do)Tj
1.253 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.576 0 Td
(refrain)Tj
2.9253 0 Td
(from)Tj
2.2054 0 Td
(employing)Tj
4.4674 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.0626 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(presence)Tj
3.7134 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(noise,)Tj
2.5512 0 Td
(such)Tj
-34.2763 -1.2982 Td
(that)Tj
1.7744 0 Td
(two)Tj
1.7121 0 Td
(types)Tj
2.2734 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(errors)Tj
2.6249 0 Td
(occur)Tj
2.4774 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(prosocial)Tj
3.8551 0 Td
(punishment.)Tj
5.2838 0 Td
(First,)Tj
2.2734 0 Td
(some)Tj
2.33 0 Td
(punishments)Tj
5.4198 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4514 0 Td
(mistak-)Tj
-33.5223 -1.2983 Td
(enly)Tj
1.8935 0 Td
(directed)Tj
3.4809 0 Td
(at)Tj
0.9524 0 Td
(cooperators.)Tj
5.1647 0 Td
(Whereas)Tj
3.7304 0 Td
(Grechenig)Tj
4.3823 0 Td
(et)Tj
0.9411 0 Td
(al.)Tj
1.1282 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(27)Tj
0 g
(])Tj
1.8482 0 Td
(show)Tj
2.3017 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7802 0 Td
(mistaken)Tj
3.8664 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.0626 0 Td
(of)Tj
-36.5326 -1.3039 Td
(cooperators)Tj
4.9379 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8504 0 Td
(detrimental)Tj
4.8755 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0262 0 Td
(cooperation,)Tj
5.2497 0 Td
(Fischer)Tj
3.1237 0 Td
(et)Tj
0.9411 0 Td
(al.)Tj
1.1282 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(28)Tj
0 g
(])Tj
1.8482 0 Td
(cannot)Tj
2.982 0 Td
(confirm)Tj
3.4413 0 Td
(this)Tj
1.6781 0 Td
(result.)Tj
2.6702 0 Td
(Sec-)Tj
-34.7525 -1.2983 Td
(ond,)Tj
2.0295 0 Td
(defectors)Tj
3.8438 0 Td
(evade)Tj
2.4831 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.057 0 Td
(from)Tj
2.2053 0 Td
(others)Tj
2.71 0 Td
(who)Tj
1.9388 0 Td
(observe)Tj
3.2655 0 Td
(them)Tj
2.2904 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(cooperators)Tj
4.9436 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4513 0 Td
(thus)Tj
-34.9622 -1.2982 Td
(less)Tj
1.61 0 Td
(strongly)Tj
3.4753 0 Td
(discouraged)Tj
5.0513 0 Td
(from)Tj
2.2053 0 Td
(free)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(riding.)Tj
2.8914 0 Td
(Moreover,)Tj
4.3993 0 Td
(resources)Tj
3.9855 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4513 0 Td
(`wasted')Tj
3.3902 0 Td
(when)Tj
2.4038 0 Td
(punish-)Tj
-32.5925 -1.2983 Td
(ments)Tj
2.6702 0 Td
(do)Tj
1.2529 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.576 0 Td
(reach)Tj
2.3981 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(intended)Tj
3.787 0 Td
(target.)Tj
2.7383 0 Td
(As)Tj
1.2642 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(result,)Tj
2.6759 0 Td
(both)Tj
2.0579 0 Td
(studies)Tj
2.9877 0 Td
(find)Tj
1.8482 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7801 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(presence)Tj
3.7134 0 Td
(of)Tj
-35.3761 -1.3039 Td
(noise,)Tj
2.5511 0 Td
(an)Tj
1.2019 0 Td
(IDR)Tj
1.9162 0 Td
(cannot)Tj
2.982 0 Td
(promote)Tj
3.6624 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.0286 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(earnings)Tj
3.6397 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(effectively)Tj
4.2066 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0204 0 Td
(without)Tj
3.3279 0 Td
(noise.)Tj
2.5512 0 Td
(This)Tj
-34.8319 -1.2983 Td
(latter)Tj
2.2903 0 Td
(finding)Tj
3.1351 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8447 0 Td
(supported)Tj
4.269 0 Td
(by)Tj
1.1849 0 Td
(studies)Tj
2.9877 0 Td
(which)Tj
2.6475 0 Td
(implement)Tj
4.5864 0 Td
(noise)Tj
2.3244 0 Td
(or)Tj
1.0999 0 Td
(inaccurate)Tj
4.371 0 Td
(information)Tj
5.0739 0 Td
(about)Tj
-34.8148 -1.2983 Td
(actors')Tj
2.8289 0 Td
(contributions)Tj
5.6523 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0374 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(way)Tj
1.7915 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7801 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8504 0 Td
(less)Tj
1.6101 0 Td
(related)Tj
2.9423 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0262 0 Td
(our)Tj
1.627 0 Td
(setup)Tj
2.3471 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(41)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(51)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(52)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
-22.9491 -1.3039 Td
(In)Tj
1.1111 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(recent)Tj
2.7099 0 Td
(working)Tj
3.5603 0 Td
(paper,)Tj
2.7099 0 Td
(Ambrus)Tj
3.4923 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(Greiner)Tj
3.3392 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(53)Tj
0 g
(])Tj
1.8538 0 Td
(report)Tj
2.7043 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.474 0 Td
(results)Tj
2.8062 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(an)Tj
1.2019 0 Td
(experiment)Tj
-31.555 -1.2982 Td
(that)Tj
1.7688 0 Td
(seems)Tj
2.5965 0 Td
(closest)Tj
2.8346 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(ours.)Tj
2.1997 0 Td
(They)Tj
2.228 0 Td
(also)Tj
1.7575 0 Td
(investigate)Tj
4.456 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.457 0 Td
(effectiveness)Tj
5.1987 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0035 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6463 0 Td
(CDR)Tj
2.228 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(promote)Tj
3.6566 0 Td
(coopera-)Tj
-34.0608 -1.2983 Td
(tion)Tj
1.8425 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(an)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.2018 0 Td
[(\r)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(-person)Tj
3.8268 0 Td
(PD)Tj
1.5194 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.9955 0 Td
(noisy)Tj
2.3584 0 Td
(public)Tj
2.7099 0 Td
(monitoring.)Tj
5.0457 0 Td
(They)Tj
2.2337 0 Td
(find)Tj
1.8538 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7745 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.474 0 Td
(CDR)Tj
2.2394 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8503 0 Td
(more)Tj
2.3414 0 Td
(success-)Tj
-34.2989 -1.3039 Td
(ful)Tj
1.2812 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(maintaining)Tj
5.1136 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.0287 0 Td
(than)Tj
2.0239 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.474 0 Td
(IDR)Tj
1.9162 0 Td
(both)Tj
2.058 0 Td
(with)Tj
2.0012 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(without)Tj
3.3279 0 Td
(noise.)Tj
2.5511 0 Td
(Since)Tj
2.3585 0 Td
(their)Tj
2.1089 0 Td
(findings)Tj
-34.0098 -1.2983 Td
(stand)Tj
2.3867 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(stark)Tj
2.1826 0 Td
(contrast)Tj
3.4583 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(ours,)Tj
2.211 0 Td
(we)Tj
1.3323 0 Td
(will)Tj
1.6611 0 Td
(discuss)Tj
3.0501 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0374 0 Td
(detail)Tj
2.4151 0 Td
(possible)Tj
3.4073 0 Td
(explanations)Tj
5.2724 0 Td
(for)Tj
1.3833 0 Td
(this)Tj
1.6781 0 Td
(difference)Tj
-33.5393 -1.2983 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.474 0 Td
(last)Tj
1.559 0 Td
(section)Tj
3.0501 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(our)Tj
1.6214 0 Td
(paper.)Tj
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
11.9999 0 0 11.9999 200.0125 339.0236 cm
BT
/F2 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.0033 Tc
0 0 Td
(Experimental)Tj
6.4441 0 Td
(game)Tj
2.811 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.989 0 Td
(hypotheses)Tj
/F0 1 Tf
-11.2441 -1.5023 Td
(One-shot)Tj
4.2945 0 Td
(n-person)Tj
4.115 0 Td
(PD)Tj
1.5968 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.9748 0 Td
(peer)Tj
2.1969 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
10 0 0 10 200.0125 303.9874 cm
BT
/F5 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.004 Tc
0 0 Td
(We)Tj
1.61 0 Td
(consider)Tj
3.6453 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.0287 0 Td
(problems)Tj
3.9685 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0374 0 Td
(series)Tj
2.4265 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(one-shot)Tj
3.7473 0 Td
(six-person)Tj
4.3881 0 Td
(PDs)Tj
1.8765 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(54)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(55)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(56)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
4.4333 0 Td
(The)Tj
1.7802 0 Td
(PD)Tj
-34.9566 -1.2982 Td
(model)Tj
2.7439 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8447 0 Td
(employed)Tj
4.1442 0 Td
(due)Tj
1.6951 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0262 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(straightforward)Tj
6.4289 0 Td
(manner)Tj
3.3676 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(which)Tj
2.6532 0 Td
(noise)Tj
2.3244 0 Td
(can)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(be)Tj
1.1508 0 Td
(incorporated.)Tj
5.6409 0 Td
(In)Tj
-36.1471 -1.2983 Td
(a)Tj
0.6519 0 Td
(six-person)Tj
4.3937 0 Td
(PD,)Tj
1.7404 0 Td
(all)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.1452 0 Td
[(\r)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.7484 0 Td
(=)Tj
0.7993 0 Td
(6)Tj
0.6974 0 Td
(actors)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.6135 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.4875 0 Td
(receive)Tj
3.0048 0 Td
(an)Tj
1.2075 0 Td
(equal)Tj
2.3584 0 Td
(endowment)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
5.0003 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(.)Tj
1.1055 0 Td
(All)Tj
1.4003 0 Td
(actors)Tj
2.6135 0 Td
(independently)Tj
5.9754 0 Td
(and)Tj
-35.943 -1.3039 Td
(simultaneously)Tj
6.2418 0 Td
(determine)Tj
4.3256 0 Td
(whether)Tj
3.4753 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(contribute)Tj
4.388 0 Td
(their)Tj
2.109 0 Td
(entire)Tj
2.5512 0 Td
(endowment)Tj
5.0059 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0205 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6576 0 Td
(group)Tj
2.6079 0 Td
(project,)Tj
-33.4089 -1.2983 Td
(i.e.,)Tj
1.5873 0 Td
(contribution)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
5.2895 0 Td
[()]TJ
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
7.4999 0 0 6.6659 272.5228 250.3559 cm
BT
/F10 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.0053 Tc
0 0 Td
[()]TJ
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
10 0 0 10 276.6614 252 cm
BT
/F5 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.004 Tc
0 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8503 0 Td
(either)Tj
2.5342 0 Td
(0)Tj
0.6916 0 Td
(\(defection\))Tj
4.6091 0 Td
(or)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.0999 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.8787 0 Td
(\(cooperation\).)Tj
5.9301 0 Td
(All)Tj
1.4003 0 Td
(contributions)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
5.6522 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.5896 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F11 1 Tf
0.7994 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
[()]TJ
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
7.4999 0 0 6.6659 536.0314 250.3559 cm
BT
/F10 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.0053 Tc
0 0 Td
[()]TJ
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
10 0 0 10 540.2267 252 cm
BT
/F5 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.004 Tc
0 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4456 0 Td
(mul-)Tj
-35.4668 -1.2982 Td
(tiplied)Tj
2.7666 0 Td
(by)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.1792 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(,)Tj
1.2246 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.9956 0 Td
(1)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0 Tc
0.6973 0 Td
(<)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
-0.004 Tc
0.9921 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
0 Tc
0.9978 0 Td
(<)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
-0.004 Tc
0.9921 0 Td
[(\r)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(,)Tj
0.9751 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7292 0 Td
(divided)Tj
3.2144 0 Td
(equally)Tj
3.0614 0 Td
(among)Tj
2.9934 0 Td
(all)Tj
1.1452 0 Td
(members.)Tj
4.1726 0 Td
(As)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.2642 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
0 Tc
0.9978 0 Td
(<)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
-0.004 Tc
0.9921 0 Td
[(\r)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(,)Tj
0.9695 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
-32.3602 -1.3039 Td
(generates)Tj
3.9685 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(lower)Tj
2.4548 0 Td
(payoff)Tj
2.7099 0 Td
(than)Tj
2.0239 0 Td
(defection)Tj
3.9288 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
[()-13()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(/)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
[(\r)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
0 Tc
2.8573 0 Td
(<)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
-0.004 Tc
0.9921 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(\).)Tj
1.4514 0 Td
(However,)Tj
4.0761 0 Td
(group)Tj
2.6079 0 Td
(payoffs)Tj
3.0671 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
[(\r)24()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
2.6418 0 Td
(+)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.7993 0 Td
[()6()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(\))Tj
1.7121 0 Td
(are)Tj
-35.943 -1.2983 Td
(maximized)Tj
4.6545 0 Td
(if)Tj
0.7767 0 Td
(all)Tj
1.1452 0 Td
(actors)Tj
2.6135 0 Td
(cooperate.)Tj
4.354 0 Td
(Moreover,)Tj
4.3937 0 Td
(under)Tj
2.6192 0 Td
(full)Tj
1.5307 0 Td
(cooperation,)Tj
5.2497 0 Td
(individuals)Tj
4.6488 0 Td
(earn)Tj
1.9956 0 Td
(higher)Tj
-33.9816 -1.2983 Td
(payoffs)Tj
3.0671 0 Td
(than)Tj
2.0296 0 Td
(they)Tj
1.9276 0 Td
(do)Tj
1.2529 0 Td
(under)Tj
2.6192 0 Td
(full)Tj
1.525 0 Td
(defection)Tj
3.9288 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
[()-13()]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
0 Tc
2.0012 0 Td
(>)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
-0.004 Tc
0.9921 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(\).)Tj
1.4514 0 Td
(Individually)Tj
5.057 0 Td
(rational)Tj
3.3278 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(selfish)Tj
2.6986 0 Td
(behavior)Tj
-33.6074 -1.3039 Td
(thus)Tj
1.9333 0 Td
(leads)Tj
2.211 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(Pareto-suboptimal)Tj
7.6478 0 Td
(outcomes,)Tj
4.3143 0 Td
(rendering)Tj
4.1669 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(one-shot)Tj
3.7474 0 Td
(PD)Tj
1.5136 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(classic)Tj
2.7383 0 Td
(example)Tj
3.5488 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(a)Tj
-35.9827 -1.2982 Td
(social)Tj
2.4548 0 Td
(dilemma)Tj
3.7588 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(1)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(2)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
2.3017 0 Td
(In)Tj
1.1111 0 Td
(our)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(experiment,)Tj
5.0003 0 Td
(we)Tj
1.3266 0 Td
(use)Tj
1.5364 0 Td
(common)Tj
3.8437 0 Td
(values)Tj
2.6646 0 Td
(for)Tj
1.389 0 Td
(endowments)Tj
5.3631 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.729 0 Td
(individ-)Tj
-34.1062 -1.2983 Td
(ual)Tj
1.4287 0 Td
(returns)Tj
3.1181 0 Td
(from)Tj
2.2053 0 Td
(contributing)Tj
5.2498 0 Td
(by)Tj
1.1848 0 Td
(setting)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.88 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.8844 0 Td
(=)Tj
0.7994 0 Td
(20)Tj
1.1735 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.7291 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.9978 0 Td
(=)Tj
0.7994 0 Td
(2.4)Tj
1.3946 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(20)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(21)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
-22.6486 -1.2983 Td
(We)Tj
1.61 0 Td
(focus)Tj
2.3301 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2756 0 Td
(PDs)Tj
1.8765 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.9956 0 Td
(peer)Tj
1.9559 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.0569 0 Td
(opportunities.)Tj
5.8564 0 Td
(Following)Tj
4.2236 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(contribution)Tj
5.2893 0 Td
(stage)Tj
-34.1345 -1.3039 Td
(described)Tj
4.0536 0 Td
(above,)Tj
2.7666 0 Td
(each)Tj
2.0296 0 Td
(actor)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.2563 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.4876 0 Td
(observes)Tj
3.6283 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(contribution)Tj
5.2895 0 Td
(decisions)Tj
3.9061 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(all)Tj
1.1508 0 Td
(other)Tj
2.3471 0 Td
(group)Tj
2.6079 0 Td
(members)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
3.9457 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F13 1 Tf
0 Tc
-36.9522 -1.2983 Td
(6)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
-0.004 Tc
0.9865 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(.)Tj
0.7143 0 Td
(All)Tj
1.3947 0 Td
(actors)Tj
2.6135 0 Td
(then)Tj
2.0182 0 Td
(individually)Tj
4.989 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(simultaneously)Tj
6.2475 0 Td
(determine)Tj
4.32 0 Td
(whether)Tj
3.4753 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(punish)Tj
2.9707 0 Td
(each)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.0295 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(.)Tj
0.703 0 Td
(If)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.8447 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
-36.0621 -1.2982 Td
(decides)Tj
3.1748 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0205 0 Td
(punish)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.9707 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(,)Tj
0.703 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(if)Tj
0.7767 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.0627 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8447 0 Td
(implemented,)Tj
5.76 0 Td
(actor)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.2563 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.4876 0 Td
(pays)Tj
1.9842 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6576 0 Td
(fixed)Tj
2.1884 0 Td
(cost)Tj
1.8085 0 Td
(of)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.0148 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
0 Tc
0.7085 0 Td
(>)Tj
/F5 1 Tf
-0.004 Tc
0.9921 0 Td
(0,)Tj
-35.6085 -1.3039 Td
(while)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.3698 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.4762 0 Td
(loses)Tj
2.1146 0 Td
(an)Tj
1.2019 0 Td
(amount)Tj
3.3562 0 Td
(of)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.0148 0 Td
[(\n)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
0 Tc
0.6973 0 Td
(>)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
-0.004 Tc
0.9922 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(.)Tj
0.9297 0 Td
(If)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.8504 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.4876 0 Td
(decides)Tj
3.1747 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.5704 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0262 0 Td
(punish)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.9707 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(,)Tj
0.7029 0 Td
(actor)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.2507 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.4876 0 Td
(pays)Tj
1.9899 0 Td
(no)Tj
1.2756 0 Td
(cost,)Tj
2.0352 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7292 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4682 0 Td
(earn-)Tj
-35.172 -1.2983 Td
(ings)Tj
1.8596 0 Td
(of)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.0148 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.4762 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4513 0 Td
(unaffected.)Tj
4.6261 0 Td
(The)Tj
1.7858 0 Td
(total)Tj
2.0013 0 Td
(number)Tj
3.4185 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(group)Tj
2.6079 0 Td
(members)Tj
3.9458 0 Td
(that)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.7801 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.4876 0 Td
(allocates)Tj
3.5886 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.0626 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(is)Tj
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
576 737.1 m
36 737.1 l
36 737.6 l
576 737.6 l
f*
36 741.2598 107.1496 23.6976 re
W* n
q
107.0929 0 0 23.6409 36 741.3165 cm
q
/I0 Do
Q
Q
Q
q
0 0 612 792 re
W* n
1 j
1 J
0 w
7.9999 0 0 7.9999 203.811 745.7952 cm
BT
/F0 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.005 Tc
0 0 Td
(Consens)Tj
3.8764 0 Td
(ual)Tj
1.5236 0 Td
(punishmen)Tj
4.8048 0 Td
(t)Tj
0.496 0 Td
(does)Tj
2.3528 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.5803 0 Td
(promote)Tj
3.8339 0 Td
(coopera)Tj
3.5433 0 Td
(tion)Tj
1.8001 0 Td
(in)Tj
0.9779 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.5874 0 Td
(six-person)Tj
4.7481 0 Td
(prisoner's)Tj
4.4717 0 Td
(dilemma)Tj
3.9331 0 Td
(game)Tj
2.6788 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.9701 0 Td
(noise)Tj
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
36 48.0002 m
576 48.0002 l
576 47.5002 l
36 47.5002 l
f*
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
81.5811 34.9228 m
237.8835 34.9228 l
h
f*
0 g
7.9999 0 0 7.9999 36 36 cm
BT
/F0 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.005 Tc
0 0 Td
(PLOS)Tj
2.8559 0 Td
(ONE)Tj
2.3669 0 Td
(|)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
0.4748 0 Td
(https://doi.or)Tj
5.4142 0 Td
(g/10.137)Tj
3.8198 0 Td
(1/journal.po)Tj
5.1236 0 Td
(ne.01885)Tj
4.089 0 Td
(03)Tj
0 g
2.0906 0 Td
(November)Tj
4.7622 0 Td
(27,)Tj
1.5875 0 Td
(2017)Tj
32.5561 0 Td
(4)Tj
0.7654 0 Td
(/)Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
153 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
154 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
155 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
156 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
157 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
158 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
159 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
160 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
161 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
162 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
163 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
164 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
165 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
166 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
167 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
168 0 obj
<>stream
BT
66.402 0 Td
(20)Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
169 0 obj
<>/XObject<>>>/CropBox[0 0 612 792]/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]/Parent 9 0 R/Annots 170 0 R/Contents 171 0 R/TrimBox[0 0 612 792]>>
endobj
170 0 obj
[172 0 R 173 0 R 174 0 R 175 0 R]
endobj
172 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref057)>>
endobj
173 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref033)>>
endobj
174 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpone.0188503.ref034)>>
endobj
175 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/A 176 0 R>>
endobj
176 0 obj
<>
endobj
171 0 obj
[177 0 R 178 0 R 179 0 R 180 0 R 181 0 R]
endobj
177 0 obj
<>stream
q
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
285.1087 680.315 m
294.6331 680.315 l
h
f*
276.8882 198.9354 m
286.4126 198.9354 l
h
f*
288.6803 198.9354 m
298.148 198.9354 l
h
f*
0 g
1 j
1 J
0 w
10 0 0 10 200.0125 707.4141 cm
BT
/F5 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.004 Tc
0 0 Td
(denoted)Tj
3.4752 0 Td
(by)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.1792 0 Td
[()]TJ
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
7.4999 0 0 6.6659 249.2787 705.7133 cm
BT
/F10 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.0053 Tc
0 0 Td
[()]TJ
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
10 0 0 10 251.2629 707.4141 cm
BT
/F5 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.004 Tc
0 0 Td
(;)Tj
0.4422 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(total)Tj
2.0069 0 Td
(number)Tj
3.4186 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(group)Tj
2.6078 0 Td
(members)Tj
3.9458 0 Td
(who)Tj
1.9389 0 Td
(punish)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.9707 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.4876 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8447 0 Td
(denoted)Tj
3.4752 0 Td
(by)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.1849 0 Td
[()]TJ
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
7.4999 0 0 6.6659 513.4677 705.7133 cm
BT
/F10 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.0053 Tc
0 0 Td
[()]TJ
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
10 0 0 10 515.4519 707.4141 cm
BT
/F5 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.004 Tc
0 0 Td
(.)Tj
0.4422 0 Td
(In)Tj
1.1111 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(experi-)Tj
-34.5654 -1.3039 Td
(ment,)Tj
2.5342 0 Td
(we)Tj
1.3266 0 Td
(employ)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
3.1918 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.703 0 Td
(=)Tj
0.7993 0 Td
(2)Tj
0.6973 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.7292 0 Td
[(\n)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.6973 0 Td
(=)Tj
0.7993 0 Td
(6,)Tj
0.9185 0 Td
(which)Tj
2.6532 0 Td
(corresponds)Tj
5.1363 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0262 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(frequently)Tj
4.3086 0 Td
(used)Tj
2.0636 0 Td
(1:3)Tj
1.3947 0 Td
(cost-to-impact)Tj
-31.4474 -1.2982 Td
(ratio)Tj
2.0976 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.057 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(57)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
-6.9732 -1.2983 Td
(Under)Tj
2.829 0 Td
(an)Tj
1.2019 0 Td
(IDR,)Tj
2.1429 0 Td
(which)Tj
2.6533 0 Td
(reflects)Tj
3.0557 0 Td
(how)Tj
1.9389 0 Td
(peer)Tj
1.9559 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.0569 0 Td
(institutions)Tj
4.7736 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4456 0 Td
(typically)Tj
3.5602 0 Td
(employed)Tj
4.1442 0 Td
(in)Tj
-35.9543 -1.2983 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.023 0 Td
(experiments,)Tj
5.3631 0 Td
(all)Tj
1.1452 0 Td
(punishments)Tj
5.4255 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4456 0 Td
(implemented.)Tj
5.76 0 Td
(Thus,)Tj
2.4718 0 Td
(each)Tj
2.0296 0 Td
(actor's)Tj
2.8289 0 Td
(earnings)Tj
3.6396 0 Td
(are)Tj
-35.1323 -1.3039 Td
(decreased)Tj
4.1329 0 Td
(by)Tj
1.1849 0 Td
(allocated)Tj
3.7587 0 Td
(punishments)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
5.4198 0 Td
[()14()]TJ
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
7.4999 0 0 6.6659 352.5165 640.7433 cm
BT
/F10 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.0053 Tc
0 0 Td
[()]TJ
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
10 0 0 10 356.7118 642.3874 cm
BT
/F5 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.004 Tc
0 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(received)Tj
3.5376 0 Td
(punishments)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
5.4198 0 Td
[(\n)2()]TJ
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
7.4999 0 0 6.6659 472.4787 640.7433 cm
BT
/F10 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.0053 Tc
0 0 Td
[()]TJ
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
10 0 0 10 474.4629 642.3874 cm
BT
/F5 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.004 Tc
0 0 Td
(.)Tj
0.4422 0 Td
(Under)Tj
2.8289 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(CDR,)Tj
2.4661 0 Td
(punish-)Tj
-33.834 -1.2982 Td
(ment)Tj
2.3074 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8504 0 Td
(only)Tj
1.9729 0 Td
(implemented)Tj
5.5388 0 Td
(if)Tj
0.7767 0 Td
(at)Tj
0.9524 0 Td
(least)Tj
1.9786 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6576 0 Td
(certain)Tj
2.9821 0 Td
(proportion)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
4.6318 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(/\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
[(\r)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
2.381 0 Td
(1\))Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(group)Tj
2.6078 0 Td
(members)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
3.9458 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F13 1 Tf
0 Tc
0.4762 0 Td
(6)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
-0.004 Tc
0.9864 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.4876 0 Td
(pun-)Tj
-35.5858 -1.2983 Td
(ishes)Tj
2.16 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(same)Tj
2.2564 0 Td
(actor)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.2563 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(.)Tj
0.7144 0 Td
(If)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.8447 0 Td
[()]TJ
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
7.4999 0 0 6.6659 301.1527 614.7212 cm
BT
/F10 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.0053 Tc
0 0 Td
[()]TJ
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
10 0 0 10 303.137 616.422 cm
BT
/F10 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.004 Tc
0 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
[(\r)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
1.8935 0 Td
(1\))Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0 Tc
1.0375 0 Td
(<)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
-0.004 Tc
0.9921 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
[(\r)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
2.3584 0 Td
(1\),)Tj
1.2586 0 Td
(none)Tj
2.2507 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(punishments)Tj
5.4198 0 Td
(directed)Tj
3.4809 0 Td
(at)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.9525 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.4875 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4513 0 Td
(carried)Tj
-34.3782 -1.3039 Td
(out,)Tj
1.7745 0 Td
(i.e.,)Tj
1.5873 0 Td
(actors)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.6192 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.4763 0 Td
(do)Tj
1.2529 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.576 0 Td
(incur)Tj
2.3583 0 Td
(cost)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.8085 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.703 0 Td
(for)Tj
1.389 0 Td
(punishing)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
4.2519 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(,)Tj
0.7087 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.7291 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
('s)Tj
1.0658 0 Td
(earnings)Tj
3.6397 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4456 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.5761 0 Td
(reduced.)Tj
3.668 0 Td
(Thus,)Tj
2.4775 0 Td
(an)Tj
-36.1074 -1.2982 Td
(actor)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.2507 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.4875 0 Td
(only)Tj
1.9786 0 Td
(loses)Tj
2.1203 0 Td
(an)Tj
1.2019 0 Td
(amount)Tj
3.3561 0 Td
(of)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.0148 0 Td
[(\n)2()]TJ
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
7.4999 0 0 6.6659 332.9574 588.7559 cm
BT
/F10 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.0053 Tc
0 0 Td
[()]TJ
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
10 0 0 10 337.1527 590.4 cm
BT
/F5 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.004 Tc
0 0 Td
(due)Tj
1.7007 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0262 0 Td
(punishments)Tj
5.4198 0 Td
(received)Tj
3.5319 0 Td
(if)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.7767 0 Td
[()]TJ
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
7.4999 0 0 6.6659 465.8456 588.7559 cm
BT
/F10 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.0053 Tc
0 0 Td
[()]TJ
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
10 0 0 10 467.8299 590.4 cm
BT
/F10 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.004 Tc
0 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
[(\r)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
1.8935 0 Td
(1\))Tj
/F13 1 Tf
0 Tc
1.0375 0 Td
()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
-0.004 Tc
0.9921 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
[(\r)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
2.3584 0 Td
(1\),)Tj
1.2586 0 Td
(and)Tj
-34.3216 -1.2982 Td
(only)Tj
1.9729 0 Td
(incurs)Tj
2.7212 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.0627 0 Td
(costs)Tj
2.1656 0 Td
(of)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.0148 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.7087 0 Td
(for)Tj
1.3833 0 Td
(each)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.0296 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.4762 0 Td
(whom)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.7609 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0.4876 0 Td
(has)Tj
1.542 0 Td
(attempted)Tj
4.2633 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0204 0 Td
(punish)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.9707 0 Td
[()16(\r)6()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
1.7291 0 Td
(for)Tj
1.3889 0 Td
(whom)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.7553 0 Td
[()]TJ
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
7.4999 0 0 6.6659 568.6866 575.7165 cm
BT
/F10 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.0053 Tc
0 0 Td
[()]TJ
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
10 0 0 10 570.6141 577.4173 cm
BT
/F10 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.004 Tc
0 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
-37.0599 -1.3039 Td
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
[(\r)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
1.5817 0 Td
(1\))Tj
/F13 1 Tf
0 Tc
1.0375 0 Td
()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
-0.004 Tc
0.9921 0 Td
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
[(\r)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
2.3585 0 Td
(1\).)Tj
1.2585 0 Td
(Actors)Tj
2.8687 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4456 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.5761 0 Td
(informed)Tj
3.9741 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(non-implemented)Tj
7.4891 0 Td
(punishments)Tj
5.4198 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7802 0 Td
(others)Tj
-32.7967 -1.2982 Td
(attempt)Tj
3.3109 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0204 0 Td
(allocate.)Tj
-3.1351 -1.2983 Td
(In)Tj
1.1112 0 Td
(our)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(experiment,)Tj
5.0003 0 Td
(we)Tj
1.3322 0 Td
(employ)Tj
3.1862 0 Td
(two)Tj
1.7064 0 Td
(different)Tj
3.6567 0 Td
(CDRs:)Tj
2.8289 0 Td
(one)Tj
1.7008 0 Td
(under)Tj
2.6192 0 Td
(which)Tj
2.6476 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.0626 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8447 0 Td
(imple-)Tj
-34.5201 -1.3039 Td
(mented)Tj
3.2598 0 Td
(if)Tj
0.7767 0 Td
(at)Tj
0.9525 0 Td
(least)Tj
1.9842 0 Td
(two)Tj
1.7065 0 Td
(actors)Tj
2.6135 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4513 0 Td
(willing)Tj
2.9424 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(punish)Tj
2.9707 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(same)Tj
2.2564 0 Td
(recipient)Tj
3.7644 0 Td
(\(CDR2\),)Tj
3.6226 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(one)Tj
1.6952 0 Td
(under)Tj
-34.2197 -1.2983 Td
(which)Tj
2.6476 0 Td
(at)Tj
0.9524 0 Td
(least)Tj
1.9842 0 Td
(three)Tj
2.2621 0 Td
(punishers)Tj
4.1272 0 Td
(should)Tj
2.9197 0 Td
(agree)Tj
2.3357 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2756 0 Td
(punishing)Tj
4.2519 0 Td
(\(CDR3\).)Tj
3.6227 0 Td
(In)Tj
1.1055 0 Td
(our)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(groups)Tj
2.9706 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(six,)Tj
1.5364 0 Td
(up)Tj
1.2643 0 Td
(to)Tj
-35.8978 -1.2982 Td
(five)Tj
1.6498 0 Td
(group)Tj
2.6135 0 Td
(members)Tj
3.9401 0 Td
(can)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(punish)Tj
2.9707 0 Td
(each)Tj
2.0296 0 Td
(actor.)Tj
2.4775 0 Td
(Thus,)Tj
2.4718 0 Td
(CDR3)Tj
2.7212 0 Td
(requires)Tj
3.4696 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(majority)Tj
3.6339 0 Td
(for)Tj
1.3833 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.0627 0 Td
(to)Tj
-36.7028 -1.2983 Td
(be)Tj
1.1509 0 Td
(carried)Tj
3.0387 0 Td
(out)Tj
1.5534 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(/\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
[(\r)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
2.7156 0 Td
(1\))Tj
1.0374 0 Td
(=)Tj
0.7994 0 Td
(0.6\),)Tj
1.9616 0 Td
(while)Tj
2.3697 0 Td
(CDR2)Tj
2.7156 0 Td
(requires)Tj
3.4752 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(lowest)Tj
2.7382 0 Td
(possible)Tj
3.4129 0 Td
(degree)Tj
2.8516 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(consensus)Tj
-32.3034 -1.3039 Td
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
[()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(/\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
[(\r)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
2.7156 0 Td
(1\))Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(=)Tj
0.7993 0 Td
(0.4\).)Tj
-3.3562 -1.2983 Td
(Under)Tj
2.829 0 Td
(an)Tj
1.2019 0 Td
(IDR,)Tj
2.143 0 Td
(rational)Tj
3.3278 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(self-regarding)Tj
5.7657 0 Td
(actors)Tj
2.6135 0 Td
(who)Tj
1.9389 0 Td
(assume)Tj
3.1464 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7802 0 Td
(others)Tj
2.7099 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4456 0 Td
(also)Tj
1.7688 0 Td
(rational)Tj
-33.596 -1.2983 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(self-regarding)Tj
5.7657 0 Td
(will)Tj
1.6611 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.576 0 Td
(allocate)Tj
3.2315 0 Td
(or)Tj
1.0998 0 Td
(expect)Tj
2.7666 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0262 0 Td
(receive)Tj
3.0103 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.057 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(\(a)Tj
0.9921 0 Td
(series)Tj
2.4265 0 Td
(of\))Tj
1.3549 0 Td
(one-shot)Tj
-32.7343 -1.3039 Td
(interactions,)Tj
5.1931 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(opportunities)Tj
5.6295 0 Td
(for)Tj
1.389 0 Td
(reputation)Tj
4.4107 0 Td
(building)Tj
3.5773 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4513 0 Td
(ruled)Tj
2.3131 0 Td
(out.)Tj
1.7801 0 Td
(Under)Tj
2.829 0 Td
(CDRs,)Tj
2.8233 0 Td
(rational,)Tj
-32.4112 -1.2982 Td
(self-regarding)Tj
5.76 0 Td
(actors)Tj
2.6135 0 Td
(likewise)Tj
3.3846 0 Td
(do)Tj
1.2529 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.5704 0 Td
(punish)Tj
2.965 0 Td
(others)Tj
2.7099 0 Td
(if)Tj
0.771 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.057 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8447 0 Td
(implemented.)Tj
5.7543 0 Td
(If)Tj
0.8447 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(pun-)Tj
-35.6483 -1.2983 Td
(ishment)Tj
3.4639 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8504 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.5704 0 Td
(implemented,)Tj
5.76 0 Td
(actors)Tj
2.6192 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4456 0 Td
(indifferent)Tj
4.4731 0 Td
(toward)Tj
3.0444 0 Td
(punishing)Tj
4.2462 0 Td
(or)Tj
1.0999 0 Td
(not.)Tj
1.7971 0 Td
(The)Tj
1.7858 0 Td
(unique)Tj
3.0218 0 Td
(sub-)Tj
-35.1778 -1.3039 Td
(game-perfect)Tj
5.4595 0 Td
(Nash)Tj
2.2791 0 Td
(equilibrium)Tj
4.9492 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(zero)Tj
1.9332 0 Td
(contributions)Tj
5.6523 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(baseline)Tj
3.4356 0 Td
(PD)Tj
1.5137 0 Td
(remains)Tj
3.4469 0 Td
(unchanged,)Tj
-32.1674 -1.2983 Td
(but)Tj
1.5534 0 Td
(punishing)Tj
4.2463 0 Td
(below)Tj
2.5908 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(required)Tj
3.6396 0 Td
(level)Tj
2.0126 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(consensus)Tj
4.286 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8447 0 Td
(allowed)Tj
3.2882 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0374 0 Td
(equilibrium.)Tj
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
11.9999 0 0 11.9999 200.0125 333.9779 cm
BT
/F0 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.0033 Tc
0 0 Td
(Noise)Tj
2.7401 0 Td
(in)Tj
0.9827 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.5969 0 Td
(display)Tj
3.2882 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0441 0 Td
(contributions)Tj
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
10 0 0 10 200.0125 317.0267 cm
BT
/F5 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.004 Tc
0 0 Td
(In)Tj
1.1055 0 Td
(most)Tj
2.2053 0 Td
(experiments)Tj
5.142 0 Td
(using)Tj
2.3868 0 Td
(voluntary)Tj
4.0648 0 Td
(contribution)Tj
5.2894 0 Td
(games)Tj
2.727 0 Td
(\(e.g.,)Tj
2.1259 0 Td
(PGG)Tj
2.2054 0 Td
(or)Tj
1.0998 0 Td
(PD\),)Tj
2.0806 0 Td
(subjects)Tj
3.3789 0 Td
(receive)Tj
-33.8114 -1.3039 Td
(accurate)Tj
3.5432 0 Td
(information)Tj
5.0683 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2643 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4627 0 Td
(contribution)Tj
5.278 0 Td
(decisions)Tj
3.9005 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0034 0 Td
(all)Tj
1.1339 0 Td
(other)Tj
2.3414 0 Td
(group)Tj
2.5965 0 Td
(members.)Tj
4.1613 0 Td
(Here,)Tj
2.4207 0 Td
(we)Tj
1.321 0 Td
(com-)Tj
-35.4952 -1.2982 Td
(pare)Tj
1.9672 0 Td
(this)Tj
1.6724 0 Td
(standard)Tj
3.7247 0 Td
(setup)Tj
2.3471 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.9956 0 Td
(one)Tj
1.7007 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(which)Tj
2.6533 0 Td
(actors)Tj
2.6135 0 Td
(know)Tj
2.4548 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7801 0 Td
(there)Tj
2.262 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8504 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(20%)Tj
1.9275 0 Td
(probability)Tj
4.5978 0 Td
(that)Tj
-34.2309 -1.2983 Td
(they)Tj
1.9218 0 Td
(observe)Tj
3.2712 0 Td
(another)Tj
3.3278 0 Td
(group)Tj
2.6079 0 Td
(member's)Tj
4.1612 0 Td
(decision)Tj
3.5433 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0262 0 Td
(cooperate)Tj
4.1272 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(defection,)Tj
4.1499 0 Td
(or)Tj
1.0998 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(defection)Tj
3.9288 0 Td
(as)Tj
-34.8319 -1.3039 Td
(cooperation.)Tj
5.2497 0 Td
(Whether)Tj
3.7587 0 Td
(another)Tj
3.3279 0 Td
(group)Tj
2.6078 0 Td
(member's)Tj
4.1612 0 Td
(contribution)Tj
5.2895 0 Td
(decision)Tj
3.5489 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8447 0 Td
(displayed)Tj
3.9798 0 Td
(correctly)Tj
3.7418 0 Td
(is)Tj
-36.51 -1.2983 Td
(independently)Tj
5.9753 0 Td
(determined)Tj
4.8473 0 Td
(for)Tj
1.3889 0 Td
(each)Tj
2.0296 0 Td
(actor.)Tj
2.4775 0 Td
(Hence,)Tj
3.033 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2756 0 Td
(average,)Tj
3.4526 0 Td
(each)Tj
2.0296 0 Td
(actor's)Tj
2.8289 0 Td
(contribution)Tj
5.2895 0 Td
(deci-)Tj
-34.6278 -1.2982 Td
(sion)Tj
1.9048 0 Td
(will)Tj
1.6611 0 Td
(be)Tj
1.1509 0 Td
(incorrectly)Tj
4.5524 0 Td
(perceived)Tj
4.0535 0 Td
(by)Tj
1.1849 0 Td
(one)Tj
1.6951 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.474 0 Td
(five)Tj
1.6497 0 Td
(other)Tj
2.3471 0 Td
(group)Tj
2.6079 0 Td
(members.)Tj
4.1725 0 Td
(However,)Tj
4.0762 0 Td
(payoffs)Tj
-33.5449 -1.304 Td
(are)Tj
1.4456 0 Td
(based)Tj
2.4775 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2756 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(real)Tj
1.6951 0 Td
(contributions)Tj
5.6522 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(all)Tj
1.1452 0 Td
(group)Tj
2.6079 0 Td
(members.)Tj
-17.586 -1.2982 Td
(Assuming)Tj
4.2576 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7801 0 Td
(initial)Tj
2.5455 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.023 0 Td
(rates)Tj
2.1089 0 Td
(will)Tj
1.6668 0 Td
(be)Tj
1.1509 0 Td
(close)Tj
2.177 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(50%,)Tj
2.1543 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8504 0 Td
(frequently)Tj
4.3086 0 Td
(found)Tj
2.6192 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(linear)Tj
-34.9112 -1.2983 Td
(PGG)Tj
2.211 0 Td
(experiments)Tj
5.1363 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(33)Tj
0 g
(,)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(34)Tj
0 g
(],)Tj
3.2542 0 Td
(observed)Tj
3.7927 0 Td
(initial)Tj
2.5512 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.0229 0 Td
(rates)Tj
2.109 0 Td
(should)Tj
2.9196 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.5704 0 Td
(be)Tj
1.1509 0 Td
(much)Tj
2.5171 0 Td
(affected)Tj
3.3279 0 Td
(by)Tj
-35.5632 -1.3039 Td
(noise)Tj
2.3243 0 Td
(because)Tj
3.3222 0 Td
(an)Tj
1.2019 0 Td
(approximately)Tj
5.9754 0 Td
(equal)Tj
2.3584 0 Td
(number)Tj
3.4186 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(contributions)Tj
5.6522 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(defections)Tj
4.286 0 Td
(will)Tj
1.6668 0 Td
(be)Tj
1.1508 0 Td
(per-)Tj
-34.1005 -1.2983 Td
(ceived)Tj
2.7382 0 Td
(incorrectly.)Tj
4.7792 0 Td
(Thus,)Tj
2.4774 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(typical)Tj
2.863 0 Td
(decline)Tj
3.0784 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(cooperation)Tj
5.0229 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.474 0 Td
(PD)Tj
1.5137 0 Td
(without)Tj
3.3279 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
-29.996 -1.2982 Td
(should)Tj
2.9139 0 Td
(also)Tj
1.7689 0 Td
(occur)Tj
2.4718 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0374 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(presence)Tj
3.7133 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(noise.)Tj
2.5512 0 Td
(Hence,)Tj
3.033 0 Td
(we)Tj
1.3266 0 Td
(refer)Tj
2.0977 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(baseline)Tj
3.4356 0 Td
(PD)Tj
1.5137 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(PD)Tj
1.5137 0 Td
(without)Tj
-34.0212 -1.2983 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.0569 0 Td
(institution,)Tj
4.6375 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(assume)Tj
3.1464 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7802 0 Td
(it)Tj
0.7823 0 Td
(does)Tj
2.041 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.576 0 Td
(matter)Tj
2.863 0 Td
(whether)Tj
3.4753 0 Td
(noise)Tj
2.33 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8447 0 Td
(present)Tj
3.1635 0 Td
(or)Tj
1.0998 0 Td
(not.)Tj
-33.3295 -1.3039 Td
(With)Tj
2.279 0 Td
(regard)Tj
2.8176 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0205 0 Td
(peer)Tj
1.9559 0 Td
(punishment,)Tj
5.2894 0 Td
(there)Tj
2.262 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4514 0 Td
(two)Tj
1.7064 0 Td
(ways)Tj
2.1543 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(which)Tj
2.6475 0 Td
(noise)Tj
2.3301 0 Td
(can)Tj
1.6214 0 Td
(cause)Tj
2.3924 0 Td
(actors')Tj
-32.1616 -1.2983 Td
(actions)Tj
3.0557 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(deviate)Tj
3.0501 0 Td
(from)Tj
2.2053 0 Td
(their)Tj
2.109 0 Td
(intentions)Tj
4.2859 0 Td
(\(henceforth)Tj
4.9039 0 Td
(referred)Tj
3.4186 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(as)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.0148 0 Td
[()11( )12(\r)18()-4()12()18()6()2(\r)22()]TJ
4.8472 0 Td
[()2()-9()20()11()5()]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
(\).)Tj
3.0558 0 Td
(First,)Tj
-33.9985 -1.2982 Td
(prosocial)Tj
3.855 0 Td
(punishers)Tj
4.1216 0 Td
(might)Tj
2.6022 0 Td
(fail)Tj
1.4513 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(punish)Tj
2.9707 0 Td
(actual)Tj
2.5852 0 Td
(defectors)Tj
3.8438 0 Td
(if)Tj
0.771 0 Td
(they)Tj
1.9275 0 Td
(observe)Tj
3.2655 0 Td
(these)Tj
2.2564 0 Td
(defectors)Tj
3.8437 0 Td
(as)Tj
-34.52 -1.304 Td
(cooperators.)Tj
5.1646 0 Td
(Second,)Tj
3.3506 0 Td
(prosocial)Tj
3.8551 0 Td
(punishers)Tj
4.1272 0 Td
(may)Tj
1.9275 0 Td
(punish)Tj
2.9707 0 Td
(actual)Tj
2.5795 0 Td
(cooperators)Tj
4.9436 0 Td
(if)Tj
0.7767 0 Td
(they)Tj
1.9219 0 Td
(observe)Tj
3.2655 0 Td
(these)Tj
-34.8829 -1.2982 Td
(cooperators)Tj
4.9379 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(defectors.)Tj
4.0705 0 Td
(This)Tj
1.9899 0 Td
(latter)Tj
2.2904 0 Td
(punishment)Tj
5.057 0 Td
(error)Tj
2.2677 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8447 0 Td
(different)Tj
3.6566 0 Td
(from)Tj
2.2054 0 Td
(antisocial)Tj
4.0082 0 Td
(punishment,)Tj
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
576 737.1 m
36 737.1 l
36 737.6 l
576 737.6 l
f*
36 741.2598 107.1496 23.6976 re
W* n
q
107.0929 0 0 23.6409 36 741.3165 cm
q
/I0 Do
Q
Q
Q
q
0 0 612 792 re
W* n
1 j
1 J
0 w
7.9999 0 0 7.9999 203.811 745.7952 cm
BT
/F0 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.005 Tc
0 0 Td
(Consens)Tj
3.8764 0 Td
(ual)Tj
1.5236 0 Td
(punishmen)Tj
4.8048 0 Td
(t)Tj
0.496 0 Td
(does)Tj
2.3528 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.5803 0 Td
(promote)Tj
3.8339 0 Td
(coopera)Tj
3.5433 0 Td
(tion)Tj
1.8001 0 Td
(in)Tj
0.9779 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.5874 0 Td
(six-person)Tj
4.7481 0 Td
(prisoner's)Tj
4.4717 0 Td
(dilemma)Tj
3.9331 0 Td
(game)Tj
2.6788 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.9701 0 Td
(noise)Tj
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
36 48.0002 m
576 48.0002 l
576 47.5002 l
36 47.5002 l
f*
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
81.5811 34.9228 m
237.8835 34.9228 l
h
f*
0 g
7.9999 0 0 7.9999 36 36 cm
BT
/F0 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.005 Tc
0 0 Td
(PLOS)Tj
2.8559 0 Td
(ONE)Tj
2.3669 0 Td
(|)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
0.4748 0 Td
(https://doi.or)Tj
5.4142 0 Td
(g/10.137)Tj
3.8198 0 Td
(1/journal.po)Tj
5.1236 0 Td
(ne.01885)Tj
4.089 0 Td
(03)Tj
0 g
2.0906 0 Td
(November)Tj
4.7622 0 Td
(27,)Tj
1.5875 0 Td
(2017)Tj
32.5561 0 Td
(5)Tj
0.7654 0 Td
(/)Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
178 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
179 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
180 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
181 0 obj
<>stream
BT
66.402 0 Td
(20)Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
182 0 obj
<>/ColorSpace<>/XObject<>>>/CropBox[0 0 612 792]/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]/Parent 9 0 R/Annots 189 0 R/Contents 190 0 R/TrimBox[0 0 612 792]>>
endobj
186 0 obj
<>
endobj
191 0 obj
<>
endobj
192 0 obj
<>stream
%!PS-AdobeFont-1.0
11 dict begin
/FontName /TeX_CM_Roman def
/FontType 1 def
/FontBBox {-31 -250 1000 750} readonly def
/FontMatrix [0.001 0 0 0.001 0 0] readonly def
/PaintType 0 def
/FontInfo 8 dict dup begin
/FullName (TeX_CM_Roman) readonly def
/BaseFontName (TeX_CM_Roman) def
end def
/Encoding 256 array
0 1 255 {1 index exch /.notdef put} for
dup 0 /C0 put
dup 1 /C1 put
dup 2 /C2 put
dup 3 /C3 put
dup 4 /C4 put
dup 5 /C5 put
dup 6 /C6 put
dup 7 /C7 put
dup 8 /C8 put
dup 9 /C9 put
dup 10 /C10 put
dup 11 /C11 put
dup 12 /C12 put
dup 13 /C13 put
dup 14 /C14 put
dup 15 /C15 put
dup 16 /C16 put
dup 17 /C17 put
dup 18 /C18 put
dup 19 /C19 put
dup 20 /C20 put
dup 21 /C21 put
dup 22 /C22 put
dup 23 /C23 put
dup 24 /C24 put
dup 25 /C25 put
dup 26 /C26 put
dup 27 /C27 put
dup 28 /C28 put
dup 29 /C29 put
dup 30 /C30 put
dup 31 /C31 put
dup 32 /space put
dup 33 /exclam put
dup 34 /quotedbl put
dup 35 /numbersign put
dup 36 /dollar put
dup 37 /percent put
dup 38 /ampersand put
dup 39 /quoteright put
dup 40 /parenleft put
dup 41 /parenright put
dup 42 /asterisk put
dup 43 /plus put
dup 44 /comma put
dup 45 /hyphen put
dup 46 /period put
dup 47 /slash put
dup 48 /zero put
dup 49 /one put
dup 50 /two put
dup 51 /three put
dup 52 /four put
dup 53 /five put
dup 54 /six put
dup 55 /seven put
dup 56 /eight put
dup 57 /nine put
dup 58 /colon put
dup 59 /semicolon put
dup 60 /less put
dup 61 /equal put
dup 62 /greater put
dup 63 /question put
dup 64 /at put
dup 65 /A put
dup 66 /B put
dup 67 /C put
dup 68 /D put
dup 69 /E put
dup 70 /F put
dup 71 /G put
dup 72 /H put
dup 73 /I put
dup 74 /J put
dup 75 /K put
dup 76 /L put
dup 77 /M put
dup 78 /N put
dup 79 /O put
dup 80 /P put
dup 81 /Q put
dup 82 /R put
dup 83 /S put
dup 84 /T put
dup 85 /U put
dup 86 /V put
dup 87 /W put
dup 88 /X put
dup 89 /Y put
dup 90 /Z put
dup 91 /bracketleft put
dup 92 /backslash put
dup 93 /bracketright put
dup 94 /asciicircum put
dup 95 /underscore put
dup 96 /quoteleft put
dup 97 /a put
dup 98 /b put
dup 99 /c put
dup 100 /d put
dup 101 /e put
dup 102 /f put
dup 103 /g put
dup 104 /h put
dup 105 /i put
dup 106 /j put
dup 107 /k put
dup 108 /l put
dup 109 /m put
dup 110 /n put
dup 111 /o put
dup 112 /p put
dup 113 /q put
dup 114 /r put
dup 115 /s put
dup 116 /t put
dup 117 /u put
dup 118 /v put
dup 119 /w put
dup 120 /x put
dup 121 /y put
dup 122 /z put
dup 123 /braceleft put
dup 124 /bar put
dup 125 /braceright put
dup 126 /asciitilde put
dup 127 /Euro put
readonly def
currentdict end
currentfile eexec
M#1H5 J6o\&rtS(#v\0\V7Fe༙OYx5-cY9^%Y6
(efIOldN"wȰ;)UƽoFg/rvV$JS8_oc@
o9-eGJp}[Do]mN=4*{ܯq=eU^t6¤.vA2*Sr 2@Y0}S/8W}efFz~"7Mԗ3T3#mAE=90}c:o|y$)|DKf{(!✱դs'Xt{r6\C~-x{jFҘ{@]##')\}7l"ۂ8c.)a0KcyZ$FX(uØ!{uh\[l^d*BֿAJyPOM lJvNab?$h:`/A[ 88hxtXX*UT<NoR^@z
!cef WE(3ZmC:A~Y&w$ř/LGjq6Sπ4E0rrdyrx˫3JLqT|heT[?bqv\6Kw0ֻ#[[#Fo碜m w#ojsnlϴ=9 Żԕ)~\]G˧Ž9#iiՋToI.9[ڔl6l_vtK"JfKPč+:
Α/ (kw}
>qoF6EQO8Ql68ůĊɻ֕GNKEvw*70Uz7+*t8w͌`уg;5unV#/-VPoWHY+H%5̶bGPgsPU
v
"h$9;Ap52@\_A-0@i:0&"MW\45@27wRItgtEa5 ew#oH}TȒ)HEY$@W`rTmŽ^xlIC' U:* 3?RCG
hk~sA9+cUɅ;eoYyv@54oR
UeYPΚmu[*՛4z3vIk9UBřR29kӧf4ی4o0H?ǚ<._VhZu*`h>S
ao҄Ã(Kh',9s&/b$fGX==s2:=x?B<Ӂ:ͪbJ*EgDEg|s8, 1 4f&raBڶ]٠}$*U"*/y"7.VgS+'Q6h"3$\އ7U9چۯj1}21WH;=|{pb=x@OѢ^[ngoDU'suIҢ!+VCAb2BsSm
x\=Q,pt響m!.;jX2_f;_$䦐>{ןŌR"=@M
k9٦LnQkջy{yg+_CJ;DU.2qKf ]cj[6$i/@f ^$JnY:4*itKD"_U5Zay";4\.a`a=Bhlru M:%_8Rx=mo9ިӍj&q&dWf?K
$r\;7oU'c{apDT=Zţ!.% c/=3tg|}AGd`#oe )hZ#Č4vQnTERz*uhc}(<T~?ԀlifF!W_Qo0>Tc?gߝv|K{&h{Qza
x
2)3jd@"wSt@![*SZ4\z;,ܵ
❦u@HpΒRMroҜq{z
(`wN
PcT(Sݣ\.]ƿ}/xb)7!P3hQRwYBІd|ՔF ֺw"m%r8= (Ah&x|Fz&E{fup&rxyzNt[AqR9M9N#C1cc9w\GCUN!RaoB$e W-U7ޓweaBoֳD(c6֧droG2tʈmV):ƣDa)r8>HrVm" cu40q?$-@;o,ZUHL6$ {%c#lV_.MBa6[+U3D?rfgv,m,۠8?4}ݏşcVRy5NRP_\Wz囔Zf}&5}Hf
ڗrm@0|NL}B婭$=;Ӻ֚Dȷ;NXf9&SR85+&W]
(
ţ8q ZITrM|bd
s娶 u" ]'Q+>@2Yƭ_vh\goܡn<g$wn_` _u\J!!.5^ ϓ/q
-s#+GzKcggh҇*FAV4cOcBGcf)=Bh(CX\@"8O{J
vXgn8nڧML'D/)(tD~/wF+Ќ:/+=z
EE0\a47 =c]c9H5vEYu{[7_G7>;12ч%V3iw\i ejS}K 74E.bo(/@Q-}]8TIռqw=5ѤrXO96z 96$oXIHLg_FeBP$f`>(R6q]htif N}HjV*dMv^?;[:4HFAe@5$۬x"mS~_wOn['[]a5N1&/8yiw; Dm֣@2Ur>xHDAɵFO\[D(ki=|[2Bo)ʽɢ=ȐU;,Э(W]lC!\OV5, aeI+u